I don't think that's necessarily true.

Jul 31, 2015
3:07:06pm

Gentleman Stan

It depends on the season. In many years, there are 2 loss teams that are in the Top 4.

If BYU is undefeated with a schedule like next years, they would very likely be ranked ahead of a 2 loss P5 Champion.

Report problem with this ad

Gentleman Stan

Previous username: (Private)
Bio page: Gentleman Stan
Joined: Mar 29, 2010
Last login: Apr 30, 2024
Total posts: 17,756 (1,675 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It's official. BYU is a p-5 equivalent. No debate now.

Bostonblue

7/31/15 9:47am

What other conferences have counted BYU as P5?

WDaddy

7/31/15 9:48am

ACC

Cheesy Gordita

7/31/15 9:48am

SEC and ACC. Where you been?

Bostonblue

7/31/15 9:49am

I just couldn't remember. I'm cheering for two teams right now, ASU and BYU.

WDaddy

7/31/15 9:51am

Oh, got it. You're pulling a nashty.

Bostonblue

7/31/15 10:02am

RE: Oh, got it. You're pulling a nashty.

SPORTS

7/31/15 10:24am

I've pulled for two teams for years..

Harrison0Yfan

7/31/15 3:16pm

ACC & SEC

kalifi

7/31/15 9:50am

Just about everyone except Utes and Aggies.

crack

7/31/15 9:56am

And the MWC...

Justinodhan

7/31/15 12:37pm

Seriously, haha. They're biased though.

Harrison0Yfan

7/31/15 3:16pm

<< Deleted >>

Buffalo

7/31/15 9:50am

So the only ones left are the B12 and P12?

Sonics

7/31/15 9:50am

I don't think the Pac12 has a requirement for its teams to play P5 teams for

Zinger

7/31/15 9:53am

P12 doesn't make that distinction, but they brag about their non-conf schedule

kccougar

7/31/15 10:03am

Big 12 doesn't have the requirement either, do they?

Gentleman Stan

7/31/15 10:14am

No.

kccougar

7/31/15 10:14am

Larry Scott all but said it in an interview last year.

PolarisPrime

7/31/15 12:48pm

Great point, was just going to mention the bevy of games BYU has with them

Harrison0Yfan

7/31/15 3:17pm

USA USA USA

CougDogg-e-Dogg

7/31/15 9:52am

They are in the sun belt conference

LiveCoug

7/31/15 10:03am

Well sure, except for the benefits, bowls, access

El Joffrey

7/31/15 9:55am

wet blanket

Bostonblue

7/31/15 9:56am

I love better ooc games. Real p5 is being in a p5.

El Joffrey

7/31/15 10:01am

Oh brother. I hope you're not this obtuse IRL.

Gentleman Stan

7/31/15 10:08am

Uh I said it is good to have better schedules...

El Joffrey

7/31/15 10:17am

Yep. I'll be more excited when we have some real inclusion to postseason

yfootball

7/31/15 11:13am

Of course they are. They are members of the Big 12.

AndyDwyer

7/31/15 9:59am

RE: It's official. BYU is a p-5 equivalent. No debate now.

Virginia Ute

7/31/15 10:14am

Let's just say, "P5 Independent"

2FarGone

7/31/15 10:22am

Well, there have always been major Independents.

Gentleman Stan

7/31/15 10:31am

Independents used to be big time

BYUFam1

7/31/15 10:57am

So we're a P5INO. Yay.

SoCalCoug

7/31/15 10:30am

So, many will say "so what?" But it is a pretty big deal. Maybe not for right

CalGTR

7/31/15 10:52am

and it is going to help in getting us better games

ColonelMustard7

7/31/15 10:56am

Became OFFICIAL when the SEC/ACC announced it.

Heinz57

7/31/15 10:59am

USU should always be on our schedule. Same with the U. I'd rather

Bert609

7/31/15 12:14pm

Utah, as they are a P5 team. Others nope...

Heinz57

7/31/15 3:33pm

I imagine the PAC views us the same way, as we play a lot of their teams

notoriousnicholas

7/31/15 11:33am

This is significant news equal obviously to the SEC recognition

Cougarpride

7/31/15 2:22pm

This is great, however it really only benefits the teams that play byu. its not

capo

7/31/15 2:38pm

Only four teams make the playoffs - BYU would have win every game

Cougarpride

7/31/15 3:04pm

I don't think that's necessarily true.

Gentleman Stan

7/31/15 3:07pm

Tom also made a similar comment that BYU would have to go

Cougarpride

7/31/15 3:11pm

i wish they would stop saying two years. one year should be good enough with a

capo

7/31/15 3:32pm

Not only should it be good enough, it very likely would be good enough, under

Gentleman Stan

7/31/15 4:20pm

Well if you say that this makes the door wider open for byu to be in a new years

capo

7/31/15 3:16pm

Neither the AP or Coaches poll are the indicator anymore

BYUFam1

7/31/15 3:19pm

Honestly, I think these P5 conference policies will help our playoff inclusion

Harrison0Yfan

7/31/15 3:25pm

This is great news! at the very least this makes us a more attractive expansion

Harrison0Yfan

7/31/15 3:14pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad