Max got a lot of Heisman love in 2008 until TCU happened

Report problem with this ad

Aug 31, 2015
4:56:46am

Y05

Report problem with this ad

Y05

Previous username: Yz1
Bio page: Y05
Joined: Feb 16, 2010
Last login: May 11, 2024
Total posts: 21,353 (529 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Can you believe that BYU has gone 20 years without a

dawgbite

8/30/15 5:34pm

You're right. Max Hall just didn't win enough games.

Beard Card

8/30/15 5:35pm

If only he had played UTEP, New Mexico, Wyoming and CSU

BigYfan

8/30/15 6:34pm

Replace TCU with UTEP and everyone probably puts Max with Detmer, McMahon, and

Y05

8/30/15 6:47pm

That wouldn't have affected his ranking for all-time QB wins.

Beard Card

8/30/15 7:04pm

he would have had even more wins

BigYfan

8/31/15 8:49am

I know. It should be easy to find 2 super bowl winners, a national champion QB,

RichieRich

8/30/15 5:38pm

A reason Utes will never understand our optimism every season

jrifkin48

8/30/15 5:46pm

? Roman

kC Cougar

8/30/15 5:39pm

Roman sucked. Should have switched to defense.

John Doe

8/30/15 5:40pm

Ha! Doman!!! Stupid auto-correct

dawgbite

8/30/15 5:59pm

RE: Always Roman Gabriel, http://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/news/article-1/Where

Cricker

8/30/15 7:31pm

I saw all of those and Taysom is close

Modiolus

8/30/15 5:44pm

Taysom is a special player, but he is not a special passer

Blue2thebone

8/30/15 7:36pm

Junior year Bosco was about as good as BYU QB's get

shakarocks

8/30/15 11:05pm

It's amazing that 100+ other FBS teams have as well. It's almost a miracle that

unctoothman

8/30/15 5:46pm

Beck was.

Downtown

8/30/15 5:47pm

RE: Beck was... better than Bosco.

dYrtbYkerYder

8/30/15 5:51pm

RE: Beck was... better than Bosco.

Cricker

8/30/15 6:00pm

RE: Isn't that Kramer's name?

Cricker

8/30/15 6:01pm

nope, it was George's password

PezD

8/30/15 6:04pm

of the greats, Bosco is probably the most underrated

Y05

8/30/15 7:46pm

I would say Nielsen and Wilson are more underrated by fans

Bill

8/30/15 8:03pm

I agree. Nobody talks about them because they played during the 70's.

eddog

8/30/15 8:21pm

sustained greatness

Y05

8/31/15 4:51am

Agreed it was Bosco only because I think he was better than Nielsen and Wilson

ArcticKat

8/30/15 11:40pm

Max Hall and Jo. Beck were both greats

Cougarealist

8/30/15 6:13pm

Yep. Max Hall is incredibly underrated by most fans. He was a GREAT college QB.

pistol12

8/30/15 7:04pm

Max belongs with the greats ones.

8theU

8/30/15 7:35pm

after what we have witnessed the last 5 years

Y05

8/30/15 7:51pm

Max coukdnt beat any team that played man vs BYU

CarolinaCoug

8/30/15 8:12pm

He beat TCU in 2007 and Utah in 2007 & 2009

SpiffCoug

8/30/15 8:13pm

Max got to stsrt in the pros. He couldnt beat man coverages... ever...

CarolinaCoug

8/30/15 8:13pm

Loved max, but he struggled against the best teams

Blue2thebone

8/30/15 8:00pm

Like Oklahoma?

PolarisPrime

8/30/15 9:57pm

RE: Max Hall and Jo. Beck were both greats

Trent

8/30/15 11:10pm

Hard for me to fathom that both were among the best in CFB

PolarisPrime

8/31/15 1:27am

Max got a lot of Heisman love in 2008 until TCU happened

Y05

8/31/15 4:56am

I dont remember that.

PolarisPrime

8/31/15 9:56am

I remember him having his own presser after the team presser in 2008

SpiffCoug

8/31/15 9:57am

I agree

8theU

8/30/15 7:29pm

Only Beck, Sarkisian and Young won at least their final nine starts.

SpiffCoug

8/30/15 7:46pm

so, you're saying Sark was, but those others weren't

Y05

8/30/15 6:40pm

BYU passed a lot more compared to others in the '80s

Ulysses14

8/30/15 9:10pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad