Nobody is suggesting that Ks is the only relevant metric when evaluating

Sep 3, 2015
12:55:03am

garyfan

pitchers. So stop with the Maddux vs. Ryan comparison. It's just dumb. You're creating a straw man and then patting yourself on the back for tearing down the straw man you created.

I suspect you are trolling.

Report problem with this ad

garyfan

Bio page: garyfan
Joined: Sep 19, 2013
Last login: Jun 18, 2024
Total posts: 37,998 (3,890 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Dodgers send Jake Arrieta the pitching rubber after his no hitter

JOPE

9/2/15 2:15pm

Looks like they just gave him the whole organization as well

RisinUp

9/2/15 2:23pm

That's hilarious.

LifeLongLakerFan

9/2/15 2:38pm

That is awesome. Dodgers can't really refute that.

jaredm

9/2/15 2:45pm

Arrieta is the best pitcher in baseball

Ad nauseum

9/2/15 2:33pm

yeah, um...nope.

JOPE

9/2/15 2:42pm

When he's on, I would say yes.

jaredm

9/2/15 2:46pm

Kershaw, Greinke, Scherzer, Hernandez, Sale, Cueto and Kuechel

JOPE

9/2/15 2:58pm

No MadBum on your list?

PenrynCoug

9/2/15 3:25pm

I'll give you Bumgarner. I am a Dodger fan with all Giant fan in laws, but am

michacoug

9/2/15 3:33pm

Certainly should be on there

JOPE

9/2/15 6:44pm

Haven't I humiliated you enough?

Ad nauseum

9/2/15 4:00pm

you have not humiliated me at all, in fact you are simply

JOPE

9/2/15 6:43pm

You realize Ks reflect pitching dominance whereas ~50% of a W for a pitcher is

unctoothman

9/2/15 8:08pm

So, who was the better pitcher in his career? Greg Maddux or Nolan Ryan?

Ad nauseum

9/3/15 12:48am

Nobody is suggesting that Ks is the only relevant metric when evaluating

garyfan

9/3/15 12:55am

He was the one that brought up strikeouts....not me.

Ad nauseum

9/3/15 1:21am

Read this and tell me if wins/losses are a good indicator of pitching performanc

Ashtrash

9/2/15 9:52pm

I'm not disagreeing with you.

Ad nauseum

9/2/15 10:37pm

He's pitching the best right now, but he's not the best pitcher

Ashtrash

9/3/15 12:22am

Career, I agree. 2015 he's the best.

Ad nauseum

9/3/15 12:36am

If I need a pitcher for 1 game I take Arrieta

wapiti

9/28/15 11:45pm

Classy. But probably in part to make-up for complaining about the scoring.

garyfan

9/2/15 2:47pm

Agree, they shouldn't have done that

JOPE

9/2/15 3:11pm

If I were a betting man, I'd say at about 10 pm PDT, it will be 6.5 games. This

michacoug

9/2/15 3:22pm

Also, in fairness, I think a lot of the guys were specifically asked about it.

SPORTS

9/2/15 5:59pm

Jake should send back the hit ball that was ruled an error.

Posting on CougarBoard