That's a valid argument, I'm mostly criticizing Station42's post.

Oct 9, 2015
8:58:14am

sheriffcreg

Unfortunately, the reasoning in his post pops up pretty frequently on CB. I'm not arguing that the Pac-12 isn't having a down year. I think they are, even if it is exaggerated on CB at times.

Report problem with this ad

sheriffcreg

New username: OPINIONS
Bio page: sheriffcreg
Joined: Aug 25, 2011
Last login: Jun 2, 2016
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

People can talk Pac 12 parity all they want but the reality is...

LumberCoug

10/9/15 7:10am

when the worst team in college football over the past ten years (Colorado)

Station42

10/9/15 7:26am

CB Logic. P12 teams beating other P12 teams means the P12 sucks.

sheriffcreg

10/9/15 7:34am

umm, so Colorado is good simply because they're P12 ? Is that your logic ?

Station42

10/9/15 7:41am

No - I'm saying it's a logic fail to conclude the P12 must suck because...

sheriffcreg

10/9/15 8:54am

actually look at their OOC wins. There are only a few left to be played,

yballa09

10/9/15 7:57am

That's a valid argument, I'm mostly criticizing Station42's post.

sheriffcreg

10/9/15 8:58am

that's fair. the fact they are beating each other isn't proof it's down.

yballa09

10/9/15 9:33am

Oregon won by 17 points.

Ute in DC

10/9/15 7:34am

I watched the game. It was anyone's game by the 4th qtr. I'm consistent, BYU's

Station42

10/9/15 7:40am

You've moved the goalposts. You didn't say Colorado was closer than the score

Ute in DC

10/9/15 7:44am

Colorado did play them pretty evenly tho. It's not like Oregon easily

hansel

10/9/15 7:51am

"Colorado was never in a position to when the game". Oregon was lucky to have

Station42

10/9/15 7:51am

it was a 7 point game with 9 minutes left. The game was definitely competitive.

yballa09

10/9/15 7:52am

Once again, that's shifting the goalposts.

Ute in DC

10/9/15 8:14am

meh, almost lost is subjective. Leading by a touchdown in the 4th quarter

yballa09

10/9/15 8:22am

The word "competitive" is much more subjective, which is why I was discussing

Ute in DC

10/9/15 8:57am

is any conference that good this year? everyone is down. it's all parity.

macaroni

10/9/15 7:58am

BIG 12 has 4 undefeated teams - three of which look pretty legit...

LumberCoug

10/9/15 8:37am

BIG 12 may have 4 undefeated teams - but you can't look legit...

Upanddown

10/9/15 8:46am

You think that they've looked good? Not only do they not play ANY defense, but

macaroni

10/9/15 4:44pm

Big-12 looks better than normal. Everyone else is "down"

sheriffcreg

10/9/15 8:59am

This thing will play out in the bowl season and I am pretty sure the pac will

Josef K

10/9/15 8:02am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad