No one is saying "we should win every game." You conjured that up yourself as a strawman because it fits your argument. What people are saying is that we could still play better than we are playing despite injuries. We're saying that despite losing people, we should still be able to not get absolutely thrashed by Michigan regardless of the circumstances. We should not require a full 4 quarters to put away a team like UConn. The point is, it feels like BYU is leaving some of its potential on the field, but nobody is saying we should be undefeated.