See TCU and Utah. Are they bottom feeders? No.

Report problem with this ad

Nov 18, 2015
11:22:31am

LegitCoug Contributor

Report problem with this ad

LegitCoug

Bio page: LegitCoug
Joined: Mar 2, 2011
Last login: May 17, 2024
Total posts: 4,145 (24 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Past P5 results during 'special seasons' (we aren't who we think we are)

macdizzle

11/18/15 11:05am

When's the last time we beat a P5 team that ended the season ranked?

LegitCoug

11/18/15 11:09am

1997. ASU.

Blue Cat

11/18/15 11:24am

ironically that BYU team finished 6-5

Y05

11/18/15 5:01pm

We've beaten a couple current P5 teams that finished the season ranked but not

cougarfan2207

11/18/15 12:31pm

we knocked Oregon State out of the rankings in 2009

Y05

11/18/15 5:00pm

Case in point why we belong in MWC or AAC

franklyvulgar

11/18/15 11:10am

More accurately, we'd be middle tier

macdizzle

11/18/15 11:13am

We lost to a bad mizzou team and almost lost to Nebraska

franklyvulgar

11/18/15 11:14am

<< Deleted >>

East1999

11/18/15 11:14am

Michigan State actually did lose to Nebraska

Walter Bellhaven

11/18/15 11:16am

Agreed. Complaining about a win is just silly. Also, even really good P5 teams

db59840

11/18/15 1:50pm

Nebraska has 5 wins. That's more than the average P5 team we beat

macdizzle

11/18/15 11:17am

And almost beat UCLA

CasualFan

11/23/15 4:31pm

People were saying the same thing about Utah in the Pac-12

Blugar

11/18/15 11:31am

But we'd have P5 $ and wouldn't have to worry about future program viability

fan_byu

11/18/15 11:15am

This^^^^^^^^is the reason to be in a P5. We won't win many conference titles

macdizzle

11/18/15 11:16am

We'd recruit better and could win in that special year.

Turnpike Lane

11/18/15 11:55am

See TCU and Utah. Are they bottom feeders? No.

LegitCoug

11/18/15 11:22am

I see both of these programs as middle tier long term, winning occasionally

Colorado

11/18/15 11:28am

Which I'd be okay with if we were P5...

LegitCoug

11/18/15 11:32am

Nothing wrong with that.

Blugar

11/18/15 11:35am

And I see those schools with higher ceilings due to the honor code

Ulysses14

11/18/15 12:02pm

My point in the OP is basically

macdizzle

11/18/15 11:30am

Agree on UCLA. Don't quite agree with Missouri.

Blue Cat

11/18/15 11:42am

Good data

macdizzle

11/18/15 12:11pm

I think we would have handled Missouri if Hansbro had stayed hurt one more

mtnKat

11/18/15 6:09pm

Bronco has the worst record against ranked teams among his "peers" that we know

MarylandFan

11/18/15 3:52pm

RE: Past P5 results during 'special seasons' (we aren't who we think we are)

JuanitaCougar

11/18/15 12:14pm

THIS is a strong reason why I think the expanded AAC makes sense for BYU

boscatar

11/18/15 12:15pm

I think indy is better than AAC. More games on bigger stages.

macdizzle

11/18/15 12:25pm

2015 and 2016 provide some big stage games (mostly on the road); look beyond

boscatar

11/18/15 12:56pm

But what you say ignores the fact that we couldn't likely get most of those

macdizzle

11/18/15 1:50pm

Sign me up

Banjo Blues

11/18/15 1:40pm

Once I figured out what I was and wasn't professionally

Tom Trails

11/18/15 2:10pm

What is wrong with some of you people?

LiveCoug

11/18/15 2:56pm

kill me now...

kotacoug

11/23/15 4:41pm

Not a bad post...some apples/oranges stuff

Downtown

11/18/15 1:46pm

P5 status doesn't make a team good. Mizzou was a bad team, P5 or not. BYU was

Real Men Wear Blue

11/18/15 2:04pm

Of course not. I'm tired of it too.

macdizzle

11/18/15 2:20pm

P5 status is fooling you. Missouri would do just fine as a G5 this year. They

ALUF 1990

11/18/15 4:25pm

Ingenuity. That is what led to some magic in the 80s. That is what gave Boise

QBarrister

11/18/15 2:47pm

BSU also has had a fair number of NFL guys during their run

Colorado

11/18/15 2:59pm

That's fair, though perhaps their success is what brought

QBarrister

11/18/15 4:26pm

and who did Ohio State lose to in their special season last year

Y05

11/18/15 5:05pm

special seasons include bowl games

I'mBatman

11/18/15 7:04pm

Agreed. I wanted to make sure this season was able to be compared and we haven't

macdizzle

11/18/15 8:44pm

The information in your post is impossible...

byu_coug

11/18/15 7:14pm

Like the 1985 loss to UTEP

baldcoug74

11/18/15 7:46pm

complete revisionist history

Y05

11/18/15 8:36pm

What a weird way to justify and defend Bronco...

Gerald-DeGroot

11/18/15 11:06pm

I don't understand. Don't most of think that we're generally about the 25th to 35th best team in the country? That

HarlemCoug

11/23/15 4:29pm

I hope most people think that. We're middle tier P5.

macdizzle

11/23/15 4:43pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad