You said ...

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 30, 2015
2:55:59pm

MormonDevil All-American

You said ...

"The stat was brought out in reference to Cam Newton having a shot to be the first one to accomplish either of those."

Carson Palmer has a chance to go to the Super Bowl as a Heisman Trophy winning QB ... But I see now you were talking specifically about Heisman Trophy winning QBs starting in the SB for the team that drafted him.

Report problem with this ad

MormonDevil

Previous username: Chareth Cutestory
Bio page: MormonDevil
Joined: Jan 22, 2003
Last login: Feb 15, 2022
Total posts: 21,955 (3,808 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Crazy stat: No Heisman winning QB has ever won NFL MVP or started a Super Bowl..

RdF3

11/30/15 9:49am

As much as Newton rubbed me the wrong way in College, he has turned out to be a

workindev

11/30/15 9:50am

Looked like another one of those kids that always got by on pure athleticism

Left Shark Coug

11/30/15 9:56am

Only because McMahon didn't get the Heisman that he deserved.

CopperLix

11/30/15 9:50am

or young

11/30/15 9:52am

young wouldnt have worked because the niners did not draft him

cougarfann888

11/30/15 9:55am

oops. I did t read the whole original post

11/30/15 9:57am

Young wouldn't matter because the 49ers didn't draft him.

RdF3

11/30/15 9:56am

Roger Staubach?

Mr Bassman

11/30/15 9:52am

He won two. They're talking about only non-multiple Super Bowl winners

SpiffCoug

11/30/15 9:54am

That were only drafted on the second Tuesday of the month by a guy named George

DapperDan

11/30/15 9:55am

Not sure what's so complicated about "by the team that drafted them".

RdF3

11/30/15 10:13am

except Roger Staubach. Who started multiple Super Bowls for the Cowboys.

Mr Bassman

11/30/15 10:14am

unless to fit the stat (which turned out to be incorrect) they're going to go

Mr Bassman

11/30/15 10:15am

Oops I just remembered, the stat was "after 1967, no team has ever..."

RdF3

11/30/15 10:18am

oh!

Mr Bassman

11/30/15 10:26am

Jim Plunkett too. Mike and Mike apparently didn't do their homework. (edit)

smokymountainrain

11/30/15 9:54am

They said never won a super bowl with the team that drafted them.

Mr Bassman

11/30/15 9:55am

yeah, see my edit.

smokymountainrain

11/30/15 9:57am

Plunkett was drafted by the Patriots

Sea Chicken

11/30/15 9:56am

He and Jim Plunkett are the only Heisman QBs to start a super bowl

Mr Bassman

11/30/15 9:55am

Right now, there are 7 Heisman QBs in the NFL

Mr Bassman

11/30/15 9:58am

There's still time! #taysom

Cougarclaw

11/30/15 9:54am

It probably doesn't help that Grossman candidates usually get drafted by crappy

cougarfann888

11/30/15 10:36am

Uhhh, Carson Palmer

MormonDevil

11/30/15 2:33pm

What about him?

RdF3

11/30/15 2:40pm

You said ...

MormonDevil

11/30/15 2:55pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad