Critique his writing, sure. But if he is wrong he was pretty informed in his miss.
We beat him up for Kyle the first time when he was dead on right with Kyle the first time. Then Kyle changed his mind.
He predicted BYU to the big 12 the first time and he may have been 100% right, as many have surmised. And then things changed.
If he is predicting BYU to the Big 12 this time, I'd listen. It doesn't mean he will be right and that it will happen. But if he is hearing there is a good chance, I'd at least listen. There isn't anyone who has been around the program longer than Dick. If he is wrong, it didn't come from nowhere.