My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 25, 2016
7:28
:39
am
AzCoug1
Walk-on
Prove it
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
AzCoug1
New username
DesertBlues
Bio page
AzCoug1
Joined
Dec 12, 2014
Last login
Jul 27, 2016
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
For those that want Taysom to start
digitalayon
6/22/16 7:35pm
No.
DrKennethNoisewater
6/22/16 7:37pm
No.
Cougarrr
6/22/16 7:42pm
Nobody knew if Taysom was even coming back
Seasider
6/22/16 7:42pm
No.
Jericho
6/22/16 7:48pm
No
Blue Ghost
6/22/16 7:54pm
No.
beebs4lyfe
6/22/16 7:55pm
Yes. Taysom cant stay healthy
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 7:56pm
Except during his run first sophomore season, 2013.
basman
6/22/16 8:22pm
Well as long as we are delving into the past, how'd we finish that year?
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 8:57pm
Well, if you recall, Taysom was very much a run first QB and if ever there was
basman
6/22/16 9:14pm
K, but that was an easy schedule. To counter your counter, he just hasn't stayed
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 9:43pm
So it's easier to stay healthy against an easier schedule? Ask Riley about
basman
6/22/16 9:59pm
That schedule ranked 38th on Sagarin - try another one
Coop
6/23/16 1:54pm
wrong, that schedule was the toughest in Bronco's career. It was ranked...
icecougar
6/23/16 8:36pm
Here are the 28 current P5 teams with a worse SOS than BYU in 2013
BYUFam1
6/25/16 9:19am
What does his health history have to do with anything? If he gets hurt, then
Kerbouchard
6/22/16 8:28pm
Health history has a lot to do with everything BYU
Y4LYFE
6/22/16 8:56pm
Yup, I think the exact same way. SO WHAT IF HE GETS HURT!? That only truly
Duke Silver
6/22/16 11:06pm
Because you waste time giving him starter reps
shakarocks
6/23/16 8:09am
There are 3 words that should never come out of a man's mouth, for any reason,
jaba166
6/25/16 2:08am
Made that mistake once.
Boxey
6/25/16 11:30am
It applies to all football players
shakarocks
6/25/16 11:38am
I "guaranfreakintee" you that you can't "guaranfreakintee" me anything about
jaba166
6/26/16 3:29am
Of courses I can
shakarocks
6/26/16 12:16pm
Well that's dumb. The question wasn't who stays healthier.
RaggaeCoug
6/23/16 8:23am
No...Taysom gives us the best chance to win.
RichieRich
6/22/16 8:02pm
How do you figure? His win % and Tanners are basically a push.
Blueto
6/22/16 9:05pm
Because I have eyes and a brain.
RichieRich
6/22/16 9:16pm
One of those two things is debatable.
The Board Idiot
6/22/16 9:20pm
It's the eyes isn't it.
jaredm
6/22/16 9:50pm
the white cane, dog and dark shades gave him away
icecougar
6/23/16 8:37pm
And Tanner had NO running game to boot
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/22/16 9:41pm
Winning % is not only about the QB - it's about protection, skill positions,
jaba166
6/26/16 3:46am
No kidding? Well despite all that TH and TM win football games at the same rate
Blueto
6/26/16 1:41pm
C'mon man. That's HIGHLY debatable at this point...even
mantis mutu
6/23/16 10:09am
no.
BYUALWAYSNUM1
6/22/16 8:10pm
No.
Bgash
6/22/16 8:12pm
No
CopperLix
6/22/16 8:16pm
No.
bbqoug
6/22/16 8:17pm
No, why would it?
Kerbouchard
6/22/16 8:27pm
No, TM is awesome but TH has the experience to go with his freakish ability
ImuaKahuku
6/22/16 8:28pm
He had only started 6 ish more games...
AzCoug1
6/22/16 10:06pm
6 yrs film study, game planning, college coaching...
ImuaKahuku
6/22/16 10:50pm
Yes? Go on....
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:34am
vs 1 yr film study, 1 yr college coaching, 1 yr... experience does matter
ImuaKahuku
6/23/16 8:52am
Nope. It has to do with how he dictates to a defense.
CaliWG
6/22/16 8:50pm
no
HarlemCoug
6/22/16 8:53pm
Nope. Had Taysom played in that game it wouldn't have been close. BYU wins by touchdowns
MaxxPower
6/22/16 9:08pm
No. Tanner is so good, he'll pick defenses apart--mostly methodically, but will
RebelScum
6/22/16 9:22pm
Nope
Epileptic Beagle
6/22/16 9:26pm
No
Rhino84
6/22/16 9:28pm
No
mexcoug
6/22/16 9:29pm
I side with everyone else. Nope.
The Dude Abides
6/22/16 9:57pm
No
8theU
6/22/16 10:11pm
No
AF Cougar
6/22/16 10:13pm
No
ashkii49
6/22/16 10:31pm
You can say "had ___ beaten Utah" for every QB since Max Hall.
CrimsonCardinal
6/22/16 10:33pm
Yes.
ragid
6/22/16 10:46pm
I am fine with Detmer deciding this. Either could do really well
Accipiter
6/22/16 10:59pm
No.
Machiavelli
6/22/16 11:26pm
No, watching him BEAT Texas did.
byucougarsbig12
6/22/16 11:41pm
Maybe. Probably not.
Gerald-DeGroot
6/23/16 12:04am
No. I saw enough at Nebraska. Passing was on point.
QC Cougar
6/23/16 12:18am
Using Neb as a measuring stick is confessing: "I saw
mantis mutu
6/23/16 10:31am
This year and last year
viper
6/23/16 11:18am
This
shakarocks
6/23/16 11:33am
Tell it to Detmer. (He lobbied pretty hard for Taysom to come back)
Y2k
6/23/16 12:49pm
Why wouldn't he lobby him?
shakarocks
6/23/16 12:55pm
Exactly. He judged him based on what he saw.
Y2k
6/23/16 1:20pm
Detmer would've been stupid not to lobby hard for him.
mantis mutu
6/23/16 1:50pm
Best Man Wins
shakarocks
6/23/16 3:16pm
Ideally I want Tanner to start and win game 1. I want him to start game 2
Y2k
6/24/16 1:27pm
Can he improve as a passer? I suppose so. He was at 66 percent of his passes
JamesWestfall
6/23/16 12:55pm
You've got a whole thread here full of people
shakarocks
6/23/16 1:16pm
Because of poor protection, perhaps???
jaba166
6/26/16 3:53am
Yes he looked great against one of the worst pass defenses in all of C FB
CarolinaCoug
6/23/16 6:05pm
Bout to ruffle some feathers but here's how this debate feels to me
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:52am
You've got one more year with the hot girl, so enjoy it. The close friend will
Ulysses14
6/23/16 5:05am
RE: Bout to ruffle some feathers but here's how this debate feels to me
B-town_coug
6/23/16 6:28am
That is one of the worst analogies I've ever heard, and is quite offensive
jdub
6/23/16 6:43am
Your feathers got ruffled
shakarocks
6/23/16 8:12am
My feathers got ruffled because the analogy was really, really bad
jdub
6/23/16 8:28am
Yeah, it'd be more accurate to say your hot GF got injured from being so hot
boogers
6/23/16 8:41am
Do u usually interpret everything in the most literal sense?
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 10:17am
Analogy, by nature, are meant to be interpreted. It was a terrible analogy
runnincoug
6/23/16 1:10pm
You realize that analogies by definition are not literal, right?
jdub
6/23/16 1:57pm
Hence the "literal" comment
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 3:21pm
First, you should admit it was a bad analogy, because it was
jdub
6/23/16 3:32pm
U serious Clark?
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 5:06pm
The problem is that girl 2 is still a little too young for you
viper
6/23/16 7:59am
Well played
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 1:10pm
The difference: Taysom gives you the chance to win every game
CaliWG
6/23/16 8:27am
Very good points! Totally agree on Taysom - he is not a work in progress at all
jaba166
6/26/16 3:42am
This post made me lol so hard. Well done sir
Ulysses14
6/23/16 10:45am
So if Tanner has the great year you are predicting, what keeps him from going to the NFL after the season?
Rhino84
6/23/16 10:57am
Ugh. My point for THIS yr is the likelihood of hill being the starter and
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:01pm
If you're a polygamist, you can enjoy the benefits of both. No reason to choose.
Accipiter
6/23/16 12:02pm
<< Deleted >>
Ulysses14
6/23/16 12:12pm
One, the analogy is awful. Two, you aren't considering everything
CFMcK
6/23/16 12:44pm
2
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 12:51pm
Yeah, you still start Taysom
CFMcK
6/23/16 1:00pm
Taysom hasn't ever played in a dropback system, so his health issues
Accipiter
6/23/16 1:03pm
Meh
shakarocks
6/23/16 1:14pm
And what an actual running game adds to Tanners production for 1st time
NotOfYourFaithBYUFAN
6/23/16 3:32pm
Designed QB runs aren't what makes Taysom special
CFMcK
6/23/16 5:01pm
Either way
shakarocks
6/23/16 5:40pm
I expect we will still get much of what Taysom does best, I think while
Accipiter
6/23/16 7:53pm
who POTD this?!
Dissenter
6/23/16 3:36pm
SO MANY TYPOS...AHH
Machiavelli
6/23/16 3:48pm
That's really a question? No.
coolblue
6/23/16 6:42am
No.
Zilog
6/23/16 7:54am
Really wish the taysom v tanner threads would just go away. can't possibly
dccoug
6/23/16 10:09am
Totally agree!!!!! Let the coaches decide, and just be glad we have both QB's!
jaba166
6/26/16 3:50am
No!
buckowens
6/23/16 10:13am
No!
fulano
6/23/16 10:44am
Tanner is great. However, he was getting away with a lot of chuck and duck
fulano
6/23/16 10:50am
Both have leadership ability and both move the offense
shakarocks
6/23/16 11:24am
Agreed. If it wasn't for those 2 hail mary's we would've lost our first 4 games
Hill4Heisman
6/23/16 12:22pm
No. Tanner is the future, but Taysom (if healthy)
byumac
6/23/16 12:31pm
no
Qbcougg
6/23/16 1:04pm
Both in the backfield at once. You choose how
HangookCoug
6/23/16 1:30pm
RE: For those that want Taysom to start
Lionaround
6/23/16 3:24pm
If Tanner won every game... we can play the "IF.." game all day long
jomo
6/23/16 4:43pm
No
GSwarriorcoug
6/23/16 5:01pm
no
yakkamole
6/23/16 5:33pm
No
ZooBlue
6/23/16 6:21pm
No
icecougar
6/23/16 8:32pm
Tanner > Taysom
provodude84606
6/24/16 7:36am
Troll
jensen46
6/24/16 9:07am
Taysom is good...
provodude84606
6/24/16 10:25am
Interesting how you criticize people for hanging on to "what if's" regarding
jaba166
6/26/16 4:07am
I agree
BYuckner
6/24/16 10:29am
no
Yakov
6/24/16 2:58pm
Agree. I love watching taysom, but his legacy
AzCoug1
6/24/16 5:22pm
No
Yakov
6/25/16 6:18am
Prove it
AzCoug1
6/25/16 7:28am
No
Yakov
6/25/16 11:45pm
Yummy....
Pride
6/24/16 9:07am
Seriously. Look at all these "what if's".....
BabyOx
6/24/16 10:11am
no
GritHead
6/25/16 11:11am
NO
Wear Blue
6/25/16 11:40am
RE: For those that want Taysom to start
cougaman
6/25/16 5:34pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad