But we needed more than a one year stop gap red shirt freshman. We had ZERO bigs

Dec 8, 2016
3:10:29pm

BYUheaven All-American

Rose knew sharp would most likely start in 12-13. This isn't a Collette vs sharp issue..... This is a sharp vs. Bachnyski miss.

Report problem with this ad

BYUheaven

Bio page: BYUheaven
Joined: Jan 5, 2011
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 38,081 (4,990 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The worst part of the Isaac Neilson story.

ag4cougs

12/8/16 1:39pm

Hindsight is always 20/20

mudpupper

12/8/16 1:42pm

And it has almost always looked bad when it comes to big guys at BYU. At least

cougaman

12/8/16 1:58pm

Rose's foresight w/ bigs is what concerns me. He's missed on MANY.

mantis mutu

12/9/16 12:47am

Did Collette play at LP? Didn't think so.

kansascougar

12/8/16 2:00pm

exactly. if they didn't play at LP we don't need 'em

johnnycarson

12/8/16 2:09pm

Sharp was an offensive liability

CMuehle

12/8/16 2:00pm

Except for the SCTop10 dunk vs Virginia Tech he didn't do anything on offense

Beat_the_U

12/8/16 2:29pm

Well, we had to meet our quota for really tall, extremely skinny white guys

Machiavelli

12/8/16 2:30pm

but here's a link to the video

Beat_the_U

12/8/16 3:44pm

And was too small and weak defensively to guard 4's and too slow to guard 3's...

icecougar

12/9/16 1:28am

I disagree

CMuehle

12/9/16 6:08am

Whether you like Josh Sharp or not, he started almost every game in the 12-13

BYUheaven

12/8/16 2:41pm

His scholarship started at BYU the same year Collette redshirted at USU.

ag4cougs

12/8/16 2:50pm

But we needed more than a one year stop gap red shirt freshman. We had ZERO bigs

BYUheaven

12/8/16 3:10pm

fair enough. but RSing Collette during the 2011-2012 season

ag4cougs

12/8/16 3:21pm

Collete was a pretty big miss for sure. I thought so the first time he played

ledfoot

12/8/16 4:08pm

I thought the same thing, he holds a good presence in the middle for sure.

DwideCougar

12/9/16 10:09am

He didn't start because he was starter material. He started because...

icecougar

12/9/16 1:34am

Agreed. I said "we had zero bigs"

Posting on CougarBoard