Stars are for subscriptions

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 19, 2017
2:29:02pm

Solomon Levi All-American

Stars are for subscriptions

We've had 4* guys barely crack the 2 deep and 2 star guys (weddle and Alex Smith) play in the NFL for a very long time.

If it makes you feel any better, sitake's ability to spot diamonds in the rough scares me.

I get what you are saying, the star ratings get it right quite frequently as well, but I trust a coach's ability to evaluate talent much more than a recruiting service.

Report problem with this ad

Solomon Levi

Previous username: UtePimp
Bio page: Solomon Levi
Joined: Sep 2, 2001
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 21,263 (1,834 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Sitake and coaching staff will need to make improvements here...

BYUgoslav

1/19/17 1:58pm

P5 vs g5. It's an uphill battle.

Backcountry

1/19/17 1:59pm

Anyone of these guys would be outstanding! I realize I'm being Capt Obvious here

BYUgoslav

1/19/17 2:18pm

I'll chime in here and concur that there are big names to come

1/19/17 11:14pm

Yeah let's wait for signing day at least

1/19/17 1:59pm

^^^^^This

Hoss Bonaventure

1/19/17 3:07pm

Ed Lamb is pretty good at finding 2* recruits and putting them in the NFL

Bensoncoug

1/19/17 2:08pm

Who did he put in besides the 2 guys last year?

BigBrotherUte

1/19/17 2:20pm

Brad Sorensen.

Everyman

1/19/17 2:24pm

James Cowser, Cody Larsen, Nick Miller.

1/19/17 2:35pm

3 guys last year

BYU '80

1/19/17 6:46pm

I would consider the following breakdown a good goal for this staff:

CaliWG

1/19/17 2:23pm

Exactly right

hammergm

1/19/17 2:35pm

Would love to see more quality depth on both sides of the line and DBs

BYUgoslav

1/19/17 3:11pm

Exactly. I already like the numbers because of how many 3* we have

1/19/17 4:54pm

Stars are for subscriptions

1/19/17 2:29pm

You can't deny that Utah's overall talent has improved with their star ratings

CaliWG

1/19/17 2:31pm

True, it has made a difference in depth

1/19/17 2:55pm

Still...

BYUgoslav

1/19/17 2:35pm

Agree

1/19/17 2:51pm

Well like the first reply said, how about we at least wait 2 more weeks.

southernfriedcougar

1/19/17 2:54pm

The star system of course isn't perfect but the rate at which players succeed

BigBrotherUte

1/19/17 2:54pm

I agree. Although someone does have to be first to offer.

FrozenCoug

1/19/17 3:14pm

Jake Heaps was a 5 star

WhiteMud

1/19/17 6:37pm

three of their four stars are JC transfers. not a slam on them, but JC stars are

riboflavin

1/19/17 5:33pm

Utah has always excelled in the JC transfer game.

FrozenCoug

1/19/17 5:42pm

They like others have struck out with a bunch

BYU '80

1/19/17 6:47pm

JC DBs quite often turn out. You're right, it can't be considered a slam

southernfriedcougar

1/19/17 5:50pm

Definitely inflated

BYU '80

1/19/17 6:48pm

Not really. You're forgetting about guys like Booker, Clay, Butler-Byrd, Carter,

BigBrotherUte

1/19/17 7:09pm

Most of those guys weren't good in their first year

BYU '80

1/19/17 10:28pm

I listed those guys cuz they were good in their first year. Utah has had 2 to 4

BigBrotherUte

1/19/17 10:56pm

Not sure Butler Byrd did anything really his first year

BYU '80

1/20/17 6:42am

He was injured I think

Backcountry

1/20/17 6:43am

Butler-Byrd started at corner, had a few ints, at least 1 kickoff td, and a

BigBrotherUte

1/20/17 1:04pm

I would have to look up all of the jcs to see ratings.

BYU '80

1/20/17 5:14pm

I don't think guys turning out is an exception.

southernfriedcougar

1/19/17 7:24pm

Didn't say it was. More of a 50/50 thing especially

BYU '80

1/19/17 10:30pm

Star Lotuleileu. UT stole him from us via Snow College. Biggest mistake in the

CObluezone

1/20/17 5:27am

Let's win on the field

Kerbouchard

1/19/17 9:36pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad