Agreed, if there is a Max Hall in the group. But Hall was an all-timer, so I'm

Report problem with this ad

Jul 25, 2017
2:01:45pm

shakinbaker All-American

not holding my breath that Wilstead, Dinkelmann or Hall are that good.

Report problem with this ad

shakinbaker

New username: Junior Deputy
Bio page: shakinbaker
Joined: Aug 13, 2008
Last login: Sep 12, 2017
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The near future of QB at BYU

Bwest

7/25/17 11:50am

If Mangum has a strong season then he is gone after this year

NacoCoug

7/25/17 11:53am

Right. I have a feeling that will go as well for him as it did for Eric Mika

WorfoSAUR

7/25/17 11:54am

Mangum could have an average year this year and probably be a 4th-5th rnd pick.

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 11:56am

Those laughing obviously never see the draft or pay attention to what they value

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 3:08pm

Uh, yes I do...

LDTemplar

7/25/17 8:50pm

RE: Uh, yes I do...

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 9:24pm

Living in a beautiful city on the Adriatic making more than most graduates?

Dissenter

7/25/17 12:07pm

+ playing basketball for that money.

TayPower

7/25/17 2:17pm

Dinkelmann has just about everything Ty could want at QB.

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 11:55am

And we could call him "Dink" for a nickname

LDTemplar

7/25/17 8:51pm

I liked when those LSU guys said they wanted him just so they could say

Harrison0Yfan

7/25/17 9:37pm

Incorrect

LDTemplar

7/25/17 8:49pm

Based on what? He could or could not. Simple as that. 50/50

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 9:25pm

2019 would be more like Dinkelmann or Wilstead/Critchlow.

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 11:53am

I know Kalani said Kafentzis would compete at QB, but I just don't see it.

jwalk

7/25/17 4:03pm

I would think that Wilstead, Hall or Critchlow would be in the mix at some point

DB Cooper

7/25/17 11:55am

I am pretty high on Hall and Wilstead.

MAcc15Coug

7/25/17 11:59am

Well, there's about a half a dozen candidates that may try and take Tanner's

basman

7/25/17 11:57am

We will see wilstead and then McKee imo

Backcountry

7/25/17 12:17pm

RE: The near future of QB at BYU

shakinbaker

7/25/17 12:21pm

Dont count out Conover, the soph QB out of AZ

Coogar2

7/25/17 12:54pm

It just won't happen any more. People are listing Dinklemann as a starter his Jr

Lance71

7/25/17 3:27pm

I think your years are off with McKee..

antiyewt

7/25/17 6:12pm

RE: I think your years are off with McKee..

shakinbaker

7/25/17 11:08pm

'19 is going to a sophomore starting QB. No way we turn the reigns over to Hoge

TheLoneCougar

7/25/17 1:35pm

Detmer spoke highly of Hoge after Spring Ball.

shakinbaker

7/25/17 1:44pm

I got the opposite from Detmer's comments.

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 1:56pm

That may be true, but start Hoge for one year or have a 3 year starter?

TheLoneCougar

7/25/17 1:57pm

Agreed, if there is a Max Hall in the group. But Hall was an all-timer, so I'm

shakinbaker

7/25/17 2:01pm

Fair, but if any of those are going to potentially start the following year

TheLoneCougar

7/25/17 2:14pm

Hall was a very good QB

hammergm

7/25/17 4:08pm

Hall was the winningest QB to ever play at BYU. If we produce many better than

shakinbaker

7/25/17 4:16pm

He had an incredible supporting cast, to be fair.

TheLoneCougar

7/25/17 4:19pm

To be fair, there should definitely be a lot more NFL caliber

Lip Gallagher

7/25/17 4:48pm

I know people love Ty, but cut back on the Kool-aid

Dissenter

7/25/17 4:20pm

Hall was a monster. They don't get much better than max.

Backcountry

7/25/17 4:25pm

Unless he thinks Hoge has NFL talent

hammergm

7/25/17 4:05pm

Yes, I think there was more to it than that though. Taysom gave everything to

TheLoneCougar

7/25/17 4:11pm

RE: The near future of QB at BYU

Andyd

7/25/17 1:54pm

This definitely seems like a good kind of problem to have.

Bwest

7/25/17 2:07pm

I think we get McKee, so until he is done anyway you slice this it looks good

Pretorian

7/25/17 5:50pm

I hope Wilstead proves to be next

wilsdad

7/25/17 9:02pm

Just because a player's name is close to our CB name doesn't mean he's the next great player.

Posting on CougarBoard