I would imagine that Saban didn't have BYU on the top of his mind during that

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 27, 2017
2:17:08pm

TheLoneCougar Contributor

I would imagine that Saban didn't have BYU on the top of his mind during that

comment. But given the chance to respond directly to "Hey Nick, does BYU meet your criteria even though they technically aren't a P5 school?" he would probably include them.

You are giving him too much credit to have everything top of mind when he makes a comment like that.

Report problem with this ad

TheLoneCougar

Bio page: TheLoneCougar
Joined: Dec 10, 2015
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 21,456 (4,119 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This is why if you think BYU should join the AAC or the MWC, you're wrong.

MaxxPower Contributor

7/26/17 9:25pm

Good call

RUNBYU1

7/26/17 9:38pm

Saban's proposal is the worst scenario for BYU.

Everyman

7/26/17 9:57pm

however, it will put forth an agenda to create a better "league" he sees the end

Nat Gas Man

7/26/17 10:11pm

Most P5 conferences have already said BYU counts as P5

DirtyWater

7/27/17 6:20am

Read his statement again. He says nothing re: cupcakes.

Everyman

7/27/17 6:48am

BYU and ND comprise the Independent P5 Conference. You should know that

AF Cougar

7/27/17 7:54am

I just think it is asking too much

DirtyWater

7/27/17 11:14am

I would imagine that Saban didn't have BYU on the top of his mind during that

TheLoneCougar

7/27/17 2:17pm

well...if i'm not mistaken 4 of 5 P5's have stated we are P5 and P12 is only

nashty

7/27/17 11:14am

ND would be a big elephant in the room on that discussion!!

BYUHgrad

7/27/17 1:48pm

We are in an unsettling middle ground, but a middle ground nonetheless

Bob Vance

7/26/17 10:06pm

We may be, but I'd rather be in the unsettling middle ground than in the MWC or

7/26/17 10:22pm

I'd actually rather see BYU give up sports than go G5. G5 is going to be so

Nat Gas Man

7/26/17 10:30pm

MWC or middle ground is the same. Even as a P5 we would soon be outside looking

kikmcougs

7/27/17 8:28am

[citation needed]

Dissenter

7/27/17 9:07am

Better to be P5 ambiguous than join a G5 and remove all doubt as to what you are

7/27/17 10:45am

Tom Holmoe should call Saban and invite him to man up to the commitment

(Private)

7/27/17 9:52am

Form a new one. But nobody in MWC is worth BYUs time save for Boise

Y4LYFE

7/27/17 9:54am

and BSU hasn't even won the conference the last two years

Nat Gas Man

7/27/17 10:02am

The key here is whether it goes exactly as Saban says (only P5 cons scheduling)

7/27/17 10:41am

And I think they wouldn't leave out the service academies. Politically tough to

BamaCoug

7/27/17 11:35am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad