Reid won with talent recruited by others. Whiffed on some great LDS talent

Nov 24, 2017
5:22:37pm

Coogar2 Walk-on

Like Mark Pope, Travis Knight, Mark Madsen, Scott Pollard, Alex Jensen, and of course Chris Burgess.

Reid was grinding the program to dust

Report problem with this ad

Coogar2

Bio page: Coogar2
Joined: Oct 22, 2012
Last login: Jun 28, 2022
Total posts: 4,546 (4 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU Basketball.

kahuna

11/24/17 2:30pm

I agree it’s time for Rose and staff to move on but this year it’s talent.

Gerald-DeGroot

11/24/17 2:35pm

I am constantly amused at those who want to toss out Coach

rockyrd

11/24/17 4:32pm

I’ll say this. The whole Kalani disaster has made me a lot less

Gerald-DeGroot

11/24/17 6:03pm

Glad my link didn't work then.

Cougarfan777

11/24/17 2:35pm

Holmoe would blow that hire.

Archaea

11/24/17 2:37pm

It seems like his time is winding down

MwangoleCoug9

11/24/17 2:38pm

That is what BYU hoops always is minus a few outlier great years

Turnpike Lane

11/24/17 2:44pm

Don't think we can necessarily jump to a high level

kahuna

11/24/17 2:49pm

Marginally better. About it consistently.

Turnpike Lane

11/24/17 2:52pm

Don't think it's unrealistic to expect NCAA BID most yrs

kahuna

11/24/17 3:03pm

Reid had us consistently more relevant. Was really successful in conference

Cougarfan777

11/24/17 2:57pm

And never made the Sweet 16 and often lost first round of tourney.

Turnpike Lane

11/24/17 3:01pm

Seeing as rose has only advanced out of the first round a couple times doesn’t

1984coug

11/24/17 3:06pm

That is what BYU is. Rose got further than Reid though.

Turnpike Lane

11/24/17 3:09pm

That's what I said. We are historically the worst team in the NCAA tourney per

Cougarfan777

11/24/17 3:07pm

Reid won with talent recruited by others. Whiffed on some great LDS talent

Coogar2

11/24/17 5:22pm

So we can hire the basketball version of Kalani and co?

cougarfann888

11/24/17 2:46pm

That's my worry also.

kahuna

11/24/17 2:51pm

I don’t put all of the KS hire on TH. We, the fans and the Poly community,

BYUHgrad

11/24/17 3:35pm

Right. Don’t fire winning coaches.

Coogar2

11/24/17 5:23pm

Given the unique situation at BYU with

PhilPete

11/24/17 2:58pm

Nope that's always been the case at BYU

kahuna

11/24/17 3:07pm

Also the last 3 yrs we have been. Really bad

kahuna

11/24/17 3:15pm

22 wins is never really bad. 1-25 now that was bad

Coogar2

11/24/17 5:24pm

That's your standard of bad ?

kahuna

11/24/17 11:53pm

CB's solution to everything.. FIRE Someone.

Count Cougar

11/24/17 3:14pm

Read again never said to fire him

kahuna

11/24/17 3:51pm

You must be new to fan boards...everywhere.

BYUHgrad

11/24/17 4:29pm

Keep Rose. Fire Kalani

Coogar2

11/24/17 4:00pm

Never said to fire rose.

kahuna

11/25/17 12:06am

It’s amazing. Time for Bronco to move on. Wish Bronco were back. Time for Rose

demon_llama

11/24/17 4:34pm

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Count Cougar

11/24/17 4:35pm

Schools that fire winning coaches rarely win more

Coogar2

11/24/17 5:25pm

This makes no sense

BYUMissouriCoug

11/24/17 5:44pm

Agree the x' & O's on offense were good

Posting on CougarBoard