Yes, he gets left off most lists because he kind of pre-dated the modern era,

Report problem with this ad

Dec 12, 2017
7:05:50pm

demon_llama Starter

but he was Edward's first really good QB.

Report problem with this ad

demon_llama

Previous username: CAFB_04-12
Bio page: demon_llama
Joined: Dec 23, 2006
Last login: Feb 7, 2024
Total posts: 7,391 (21 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Do you consider Gary Sheide to be an all time great BYU quarterback?

eddog

12/12/17 6:35pm

All that plus his years of association with the program.

kccougar

12/12/17 6:37pm

Yes he was

BigYfan

12/12/17 6:37pm

Top 5? No. Top 15? Probably

Dynasty1

12/12/17 6:42pm

No Question About It

Uncle Bluto

12/12/17 6:42pm

He got hurt in the Fiesta Bowl in 1974

OU Cougar

12/12/17 6:42pm

Yep—total cheap shot by an opposing lineman!

Fervent Cougar

12/12/17 6:49pm

96 Cotton Bowl wasn't too shabby either

Michael McQuain

12/12/17 7:34pm

Back in 1974 the Fiesta Bowl was more like the Vegas Bowl today.

CougarThug

12/12/17 7:42pm

Yes!

Fervent Cougar

12/12/17 6:48pm

where is the cutoff for all time great? 5? 10? 15?

BlueFrog

12/12/17 6:54pm

Yes, he gets left off most lists because he kind of pre-dated the modern era,

demon_llama

12/12/17 7:05pm

He's part of the pantheon.

Freddie Cougar

12/12/17 7:17pm

i knew him when he lived in Virginia, legitimately good dude!

Andyd

12/13/17 3:01am

This picture of QBU includes him:

BlueForLife

12/13/17 7:41am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad