I know what went down, and I probably would have

Report problem with this ad

Dec 15, 2017
5:41:38pm

rockhound All-American

fired him too.

Report problem with this ad

rockhound

Previous username: stanc
Bio page: rockhound
Joined: Jul 5, 2002
Last login: May 19, 2024
Total posts: 8,773 (4 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Are the Reids still estranged from BYU? Most administrators from 1996 are

84 Grad

12/15/17 3:44pm

I would assume so. His firing was not handled well at all.

Indy Coug

12/15/17 3:46pm

How were they supposed to handle it?

wapiti

12/15/17 4:26pm

He had earned the right to try and fix it. Losing Bradley hurt us. Roger would have solved the problem.

HarlemCoug

12/15/17 4:30pm

Don't forget losing Ruffner at the beginning of the season

fan_byu

12/15/17 4:37pm

All those issues sound a lot like what Ty dealt with this year. Similar result.

TailgateU

12/15/17 7:43pm

But Ty never told recruits stupid things.

pspack41

12/16/17 5:04am

Different that Ty is eternally likable but Roger had a serious long-term PR prob

HootnHoller

12/16/17 11:35am

Wait until after the season or at least until after Christmas.

84 Grad

12/15/17 4:49pm

Reid needed to go. His personality sucked, mostly due to his jealousy of

pappabear246

12/15/17 6:15pm

No. And he fared just fine against Majerus.

Carnac

12/15/17 9:28pm

In the early years. By the time of the firing, BYU had lost three straight to

84 Grad

12/15/17 9:37pm

Yet despite losing those 3 straight he was still 9-9 vs Utah for his career

icecougar

12/16/17 12:21am

Tell me another coach who can say that? Winning record over Majerus? I

Cougarfan777

12/16/17 2:38am

Everything you said is so false. you have no clue

dizthewiz

12/15/17 10:49pm

Well, for one thing, if you do it during the season, you don't do it right before Christmas.

Brisco

12/16/17 1:30am

I was very embarrassed by the way that was

Banjo Blues

12/15/17 4:59pm

Reid was not going to be fired when he went to talk to Pres. Bateman that day.

Monomachos

12/15/17 11:23pm

Bateman should’ve been fired.

icecougar

12/16/17 12:29am

Uh, you realize President Bateman was Elder Bateman of the Seventy, right?

Skysthelimit

12/16/17 1:10am

They'll be estranged from BYU until 8 million Mormons pass away and forget about them.

AndyDwyer

12/15/17 3:47pm

<< Deleted >>

azmbacougar

12/15/17 3:57pm

Can't blame them

TaiJuan

12/15/17 4:12pm

I don't blame them for not liking BYU but I don’t understand cheering for Utah.

Brigham

12/15/17 4:27pm

That's ridiculous after what BYU did for Robbie

AZ Coug

12/15/17 5:28pm

Robbie has every reason to hate BYU - leaders at BYU screwed the Reids over and BYU has been unapologetic about it.

HarlemCoug

12/15/17 5:46pm

No more than the Reids screwed over Ryan Cuff

pappabear246

12/15/17 6:19pm

Cuff couldn't/did't get minutes at ASU. even after he'd been home from his mission for years and had a chance to

HarlemCoug

12/15/17 7:00pm

It was time for Reid to go. His ability to recruit was done. But Ryan Cuff and

Lance71

12/15/17 9:16pm

Ryan Cuff is one of the very best high school players I have ever seen.

Blue2thebone

12/15/17 10:53pm

Cuff was my next door neighbor at BYU his freshman year. I love the guy. Total class act BUT...

HarlemCoug

12/16/17 3:21am

Seriously?

Lionaround

12/16/17 10:02am

sorry - edited my post - I meant to say he couldn't get minutes at ASU. But my point stands. Robbie started all but 3

HarlemCoug

12/16/17 10:40am

He was better than both. IMO

Blue2thebone

12/15/17 10:58pm

Cuff was no good. Worse in the locker room. Period.

Cougarfan777

12/16/17 2:40am

Why do you say that?

Blue2thebone

12/16/17 8:39am

I’d rather go play at Michigan than BYU anyway

dizthewiz

12/15/17 10:51pm

Robbie & Randy were hardly equals in this equation, though.

mantis mutu

12/16/17 1:32am

<< Deleted >>

HarlemCoug

12/16/17 3:27am

If you knew the whole story of Roger Reid and how he was fired and what the last

Paul Hewson

12/15/17 5:27pm

I know what went down, and I probably would have

rockhound

12/15/17 5:41pm

I hate it when people comment like this and give ZERO information. If you're not

Skysthelimit

12/15/17 6:34pm

But it’s so fun to let people know how much you know!

Disco LaFleur

12/15/17 7:15pm

I doubt they even really know

LifelongAP

12/15/17 8:49pm

I know his sister and while I think there is sadness about it, she loves byu.

blueaussie

12/15/17 6:06pm

Randy is an all around great guy, but yes, their is still some animosity

Captain Stubing

12/15/17 6:50pm

<< Deleted >>

VenetianCougar

12/15/17 7:02pm

Didn't he win like 2 games one year?

ugo1st

12/15/17 7:15pm

Curiosity killed the cat. He won one game in his last year before being fired.

ugo1st

12/15/17 7:21pm

Steve Cleveland had to clean up the mess he left behind

pspack41

12/15/17 7:57pm

1 and 6 at the time he was fired. However the night before, attendance at the

84 Grad

12/15/17 7:23pm

Roger could be a jerk and badly needed to be fired

Coogar2

12/15/17 7:34pm

Randy is my neighbor....

CoachSpeak

12/16/17 6:51am

Knowing you are a fan and who he was says a lot if it is never mentioned.

RealityCheck

12/16/17 11:09am

As some of you know, I grew up a Ute fan. I've converted to BYU in every

cougar_chick1

12/16/17 9:27am

It was the circumcision hair cuts, wasn't it?

AZ Coug

12/16/17 3:02pm

You nailed it!

Posting on CougarBoard