May 13, 2024
9:05:11am
9:05:11am
Murphy? Hall of Very Good. Only 46.5 bWAR, 37th best all-time at his position.
We are talking about guys like Curtis Granderson and Tori Hunter who were more valuable and had better/similar careers.
Looking at only peak years, he does better, but still only 18th all time at his position in WAR7, behind guys like Carlos Beltran (probably a HOFer) and Jim Edmonds (not a HOF). He’s 3 WAR7 behind the average of the current HOFers at his position (and that’s the more favorable metric).
Not a HOFer.
Looking at only peak years, he does better, but still only 18th all time at his position in WAR7, behind guys like Carlos Beltran (probably a HOFer) and Jim Edmonds (not a HOF). He’s 3 WAR7 behind the average of the current HOFers at his position (and that’s the more favorable metric).
Not a HOFer.
- Previous username
- TCuz13
- Bio page
- TCuz
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2014
- Last login
- May 23, 2024
- Total posts
- 58,799 (19,286 FO)
