Lots of if, I think, may have, it seems, but initial posts are way more bold and declarative.
You described not knowing lwhat actually happened but for some reason trust Tang’s statement and then backward map it over the whole situation.
You may very well have some insight that is helpful but the tone and delivery and theme that BYU has it wrong - every time - cause erosion in confidence.
Have you thought perhaps that conjecture and criticism may contribute to unwarranted mistrust and negativity? That it could also have an effect on some recruits?