My Account
Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jan 18, 2012
4:10
:16
pm
PhillyYFan
Actually, there was a study done a couple yrs...
... ago that claimed that Scout.com was more accurate in regards to how their recruiting rankings panned out. I will try to find it again.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
PhillyYFan
Bio page
PhillyYFan
Joined
Feb 10, 2002
Last login
Nov 19, 2013
Total posts
21,612 (6 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
So is Utah kicking the crap out of us in recruiting?
ChopperDave
1/18/12 3:54pm
Yes.
WJCougar
1/18/12 3:55pm
Troy Hinds?
Ron Mexico
1/18/12 3:57pm
Meant to be under main thread
Ron Mexico
1/18/12 3:58pm
From what I understand....
WJCougar
1/18/12 3:58pm
Troy, yeah, that was a slip
ChopperDave
1/18/12 4:04pm
According to Rivals, yes. According to Scout, no.
Tokolosh
1/18/12 3:56pm
And this is a very small class for BYU this year.
kccougar
1/18/12 3:57pm
I think we had a similarly small class last year
Douger
1/18/12 4:04pm
So in conclusion, who knows?
lawyer
1/18/12 3:58pm
Rivals is the more respected site nationally
ChopperDave
1/18/12 4:04pm
Actually, there was a study done a couple yrs...
PhillyYFan
1/18/12 4:10pm
No, they are not-The average kid going to each school
kimdaddy35
1/18/12 4:07pm
RE: So is Utah kicking the crap out of us in recruiting?
jpal1397
1/18/12 3:57pm
Hardly, our classes are basically rated the same
therock
1/18/12 3:57pm
If Scout has Utah 4 Spots better than Utah is doing well
jdart
1/18/12 4:02pm
Class size has affected the overall ratings on scout and
raidingtombs
1/18/12 4:04pm
By comparission, Rivals has Utah at 28 and byu not in top 50
jdart
1/18/12 4:04pm
The recruiting quality is about the same on both sites
kimdaddy35
1/18/12 4:08pm
With out your 5 extra recruits BYU would be killing Utah on
Bluedomination
1/18/12 4:06pm
The only reason Utah is higher is due to the # of commits
therock
1/18/12 4:06pm
I'm a Utah fan, I don't read Scout
jdart
1/18/12 4:08pm
But you certainly don't have a problem quoting it and being
darkcoug
1/18/12 4:40pm
Here are the numbers.
raidingtombs
1/18/12 4:08pm
Rivals numbers:
jdart
1/18/12 4:15pm
If either fan base looks at ESPN we are both unhappy ;)
Bluedomination
1/18/12 4:25pm
Rivals numbers for BYU is 2.93. Kolton Dohnovan is going to
Bluedomination
1/18/12 4:33pm
I actually think that Utah was ranked higher than BYU last
Zinger
1/18/12 4:20pm
Of course Utah's JC's (JC's ALWAYS have padded stars) are
darkcoug
1/18/12 4:41pm
Rocky Hinds? USC transfer to UNLV
Jericho
1/18/12 3:57pm
Look up all of the cougar stat tweets and you will see that
Bluedomination
1/18/12 3:58pm
Why do you think Utah fans are so happy to get invited to
Crazy Cajun
1/18/12 3:59pm
They got lucky in many regards though
Jericho
1/18/12 4:01pm
RE: They got lucky in many regards though
jpal1397
1/18/12 4:04pm
I love this
jdart
1/18/12 4:05pm
Riley would have played a quarter and a half and gotten hurt
OGSuperfan
1/19/12 8:31am
So even tho most Ute fans admit the past 2 yrs recruiting...
PhillyYFan
1/18/12 4:04pm
example of what drugs can do to the brain
bluelands
1/18/12 4:31pm
Looks like past recruiting years at the Ewe. A handful of
raidingtombs
1/18/12 4:03pm
They've had more than a few JC kids pan out:
tibbyss09
1/19/12 11:13am
We need to be better at this
Douger
1/19/12 11:34am
February championship means squat when you lose
WDaddy
1/18/12 4:03pm
So now we lose both championships
ChopperDave
1/18/12 4:04pm
Doh!
WDaddy
1/18/12 7:10pm
Amazing that they mean so much to the Utes all of a sudden.
kccougar
1/18/12 4:32pm
We should just pack it in.
Bob Vance
1/18/12 4:11pm
Yeah, that's what I'm saying
ChopperDave
1/18/12 4:29pm
If you factor in our RMs, no, though honestly
I'mBatman
1/18/12 8:03pm
On paper maybe. That doesn't always translate into more
Byu Badger
1/19/12 1:18am
My point was never that Utah would not recruit better...
BluePuppy
1/19/12 9:23am
Yep, they sure haven't got a recruiting boost from the P12
therock
1/19/12 10:14am
Not really. They're still ranked in the mid-40's to low 50's
Melkor
1/19/12 7:39pm
No. BYU and Utah have very comparable...
Melkor
1/19/12 7:35pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad