My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 26, 2017
12:35
:58
pm
BrutustheBrash
Contributor
Disagree
It's arguable that Bosco should've won the heisman. He's a top 4-5 QB in school history (behind Young, McMahon, and Detmer -- on similar ground to Wilson). That sounds pretty tier 1 to me.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
BrutustheBrash
New username
Ghost Pirate LeChuck
Bio page
BrutustheBrash
Joined
Sep 15, 2015
Last login
Aug 26, 2022
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Quarterback Tiers
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 9:56am
I think most would put Taysom in your Tier 2.
garyfan
4/26/17 9:57am
No. He kept getting hurt before he became great. Then his senior year cemented
chazen
4/26/17 11:44am
Probably fair. But he seems like a sentimental favorite.
garyfan
4/26/17 11:48am
RE: Quarterback Tiers
socorny
4/26/17 9:57am
Max Hall should be in Tier 1.
BYUtka
4/26/17 9:58am
Yup, winningest BYU QB should be in Tier 1.
socorny
4/26/17 10:00am
<< Deleted >>
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:02am
Team accomplishment puts you in top tier of positions?
Lip Gallagher
4/26/17 1:21pm
Great point
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:02am
I always felt that Beck was better than Hall.
Mises
4/26/17 12:27pm
Beck better than Hall.
LoyaltotheRoyal
4/26/17 12:39pm
Hall was undrafted
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 12:45pm
I agree. Not to mention Hall lucked out on one of the easiest scheduling stretches in modern history
indocoug
4/26/17 12:50pm
I'd put Ryan Hancock in somewhere. Maybe Tier 2.5.
DB Cooper
4/26/17 10:06am
Does Sheide belong in tier 1? Seems more tier 2.
Dr T-bone
4/26/17 10:10am
I would put Bosco in tier 2...he won the Natty, but not in the same category
Nat Gas Man
4/26/17 10:13am
Yeah 5 tiers would make things easier...
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:29am
Just do UHSAA style--Keep making more tiers until everyone is happy
22jrob22
4/26/17 2:39pm
Disagree
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 12:35pm
I am too young to know much about Sheide
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:24am
Probably need to wait a few years, but I'd at least put Taysom on the same tier
Still Questing
4/26/17 10:12am
Taysom's 2016 season tarnished my thoughts
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:28am
That's fair, but my point is that you're giving Doman too much credit
Still Questing
4/26/17 10:39am
Don't agree.
Cougstreak
4/26/17 3:38pm
Not hard at all to argue with those numbers. No adjustment for SOS? Only 1 yr?
Still Questing
4/26/17 4:04pm
Tier 3: Bud Belnap
84 Grad
4/26/17 10:14am
Quarterback Tears
MormonThug
4/26/17 10:26am
V. Carter in Tier 1 -- a lot of people don't remember how sensational he was. Also -- Max in Tier 1.
lightmann
4/26/17 10:28am
I've heard that about Virgil from several who watched him play
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 12:49pm
RE: I've heard that about Virgil from several who watched him play
Bullrider
4/26/17 1:51pm
I think you need more tiers
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 11:13am
Hill>Doman>Walsh
Modiolus
4/26/17 11:14am
Walsh>Hill>Doman
84 Grad
4/26/17 11:20am
Walsh>Doman>Hill
Napoli
4/26/17 11:21am
Walsh< Hill >Doman
Pistol Shrimp
4/26/17 12:56pm
I'd put Doman in tier 3 and Taysom in tier 2.
Nemesis
4/26/17 11:31am
Here's how I would do 5 tiers
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 11:37am
I like it! In a year, it will be easy for Mangum to pass Nelson
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 11:59am
I like that, although I might put Beck in your Tier 2 - based on his senior year, though, so maybe Tier 3 works overall
byukirty
4/26/17 12:09pm
Giff is a College Football HOF inductee
Y05
4/26/17 2:54pm
You are correct
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 3:07pm
John Beck is a Tier 2 and Riley Nelson is a Tier 5. Other than that, its great
YouPuntYouDye
4/26/17 3:48pm
Just curious what your criteria is for QBs to qualify for the different tiers.
Seasider
4/26/17 11:39am
National awards, talent, team ranking, conference championships (when applicable
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 11:56am
how would they rank if it were just the national awards?
Nat Gas Man
4/26/17 2:41pm
Yeah that is probably giving Doman too much credit
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 11:54am
RE: Quarterback Tiers
kbufcoug
4/26/17 1:38pm
You need a tier 1b. for Taysom only
Thug Mormons
4/26/17 2:59pm
Tanner at tier 3, but no Christian Stewart?
imcain801
4/26/17 3:20pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad