My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 26, 2017
10:28
:57
am
lightmann
All-American
V. Carter in Tier 1 -- a lot of people don't remember how sensational he was. Also -- Max in Tier 1.
Winningest BYU QB (as has been stated).
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Apr 26, 2017 at 10:28:57am
Message modified by lightmann on Apr 26, 2017 at 10:30:40am
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
lightmann
Previous username
llightmann
Bio page
lightmann
Joined
Aug 3, 2004
Last login
May 14, 2024
Total posts
36,495 (493 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Quarterback Tiers
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 9:56am
I think most would put Taysom in your Tier 2.
garyfan
4/26/17 9:57am
No. He kept getting hurt before he became great. Then his senior year cemented
chazen
4/26/17 11:44am
Probably fair. But he seems like a sentimental favorite.
garyfan
4/26/17 11:48am
RE: Quarterback Tiers
socorny
4/26/17 9:57am
Max Hall should be in Tier 1.
BYUtka
4/26/17 9:58am
Yup, winningest BYU QB should be in Tier 1.
socorny
4/26/17 10:00am
<< Deleted >>
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:02am
Team accomplishment puts you in top tier of positions?
Lip Gallagher
4/26/17 1:21pm
Great point
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:02am
I always felt that Beck was better than Hall.
Mises
4/26/17 12:27pm
Beck better than Hall.
LoyaltotheRoyal
4/26/17 12:39pm
Hall was undrafted
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 12:45pm
I agree. Not to mention Hall lucked out on one of the easiest scheduling stretches in modern history
indocoug
4/26/17 12:50pm
I'd put Ryan Hancock in somewhere. Maybe Tier 2.5.
DB Cooper
4/26/17 10:06am
Does Sheide belong in tier 1? Seems more tier 2.
Dr T-bone
4/26/17 10:10am
I would put Bosco in tier 2...he won the Natty, but not in the same category
Nat Gas Man
4/26/17 10:13am
Yeah 5 tiers would make things easier...
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:29am
Just do UHSAA style--Keep making more tiers until everyone is happy
22jrob22
4/26/17 2:39pm
Disagree
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 12:35pm
I am too young to know much about Sheide
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:24am
Probably need to wait a few years, but I'd at least put Taysom on the same tier
Still Questing
4/26/17 10:12am
Taysom's 2016 season tarnished my thoughts
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 10:28am
That's fair, but my point is that you're giving Doman too much credit
Still Questing
4/26/17 10:39am
Don't agree.
Cougstreak
4/26/17 3:38pm
Not hard at all to argue with those numbers. No adjustment for SOS? Only 1 yr?
Still Questing
4/26/17 4:04pm
Tier 3: Bud Belnap
84 Grad
4/26/17 10:14am
Quarterback Tears
MormonThug
4/26/17 10:26am
V. Carter in Tier 1 -- a lot of people don't remember how sensational he was. Also -- Max in Tier 1.
lightmann
4/26/17 10:28am
I've heard that about Virgil from several who watched him play
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 12:49pm
RE: I've heard that about Virgil from several who watched him play
Bullrider
4/26/17 1:51pm
I think you need more tiers
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 11:13am
Hill>Doman>Walsh
Modiolus
4/26/17 11:14am
Walsh>Hill>Doman
84 Grad
4/26/17 11:20am
Walsh>Doman>Hill
Napoli
4/26/17 11:21am
Walsh< Hill >Doman
Pistol Shrimp
4/26/17 12:56pm
I'd put Doman in tier 3 and Taysom in tier 2.
Nemesis
4/26/17 11:31am
Here's how I would do 5 tiers
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 11:37am
I like it! In a year, it will be easy for Mangum to pass Nelson
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 11:59am
I like that, although I might put Beck in your Tier 2 - based on his senior year, though, so maybe Tier 3 works overall
byukirty
4/26/17 12:09pm
Giff is a College Football HOF inductee
Y05
4/26/17 2:54pm
You are correct
BrutustheBrash
4/26/17 3:07pm
John Beck is a Tier 2 and Riley Nelson is a Tier 5. Other than that, its great
YouPuntYouDye
4/26/17 3:48pm
Just curious what your criteria is for QBs to qualify for the different tiers.
Seasider
4/26/17 11:39am
National awards, talent, team ranking, conference championships (when applicable
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 11:56am
how would they rank if it were just the national awards?
Nat Gas Man
4/26/17 2:41pm
Yeah that is probably giving Doman too much credit
D.T. Survivor
4/26/17 11:54am
RE: Quarterback Tiers
kbufcoug
4/26/17 1:38pm
You need a tier 1b. for Taysom only
Thug Mormons
4/26/17 2:59pm
Tanner at tier 3, but no Christian Stewart?
imcain801
4/26/17 3:20pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad