I looked this up once. The difference as I understood it was that Max started under center and then directed his talk

Jan 21, 2020
11:17:20pm

mvtoro Scrub

to the sideline. I don’t think that makes any difference in a game where shotgun is more common than under center, but that was the difference in this rule as I read it.

Report problem with this ad

mvtoro

Bio page: mvtoro
Joined: Nov 28, 2006
Last login: Jun 9, 2024
Total posts: 11,856 (764 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Remember when BYU got penalized for this trick play?

Santos L. Halper

1/21/20 10:23am

IIRC weren't we penalized for what Max was shouting rather than the formation itself?

byujag

1/21/20 10:27am

The penalty Max got for that was a subjective penalty. Shouldn’t’ve been called.

BYUforlife

1/21/20 10:28am

That's what I always thought. We scored the TD anyway so I'm not real butthurt

Santos L. Halper

1/21/20 10:35am

It depends what the QB was saying

StantonMac

1/21/20 10:40am

In other words... what byujag said. 🙂

StantonMac

1/21/20 10:41am

As i Recall we got penalized for deceiving the opposition. It was a MWC rule

pappabear246

1/21/20 12:16pm

"Deceiving the opposition".......what a fricking joke of a call. SMH....

BleedCougarBlue2

1/21/20 12:46pm

Conferences can't have different rules than the NCAA

StantonMac

1/21/20 12:51pm

It wasn't a new rule. It was supposedly enforcing one

pappabear246

1/21/20 6:34pm

"Brilliant" play, by the way. Sheer genius. I love trick plays. In HS we......

BleedCougarBlue2

1/21/20 12:47pm

Flip! An opportunity to claim the world is against BYU shot down

CallingDingo

1/21/20 1:19pm

Hall said “Hey Broseph! Did you just throw a burrito out the window?”

RexKwanDan

1/21/20 2:04pm

The ref just made up something to call on us due to some sort of bias.

Mitty

1/21/20 2:52pm

I was looking for Kalani’s 4th and 21 fake punt out of our end zone.....

icecougar

1/21/20 6:21pm

I looked this up once. The difference as I understood it was that Max started under center and then directed his talk

Posting on CougarBoard