If there were a bunch of G5 QBs putting up 200 efficiencies against G5 teams, then they might have a point

Report problem with this ad

Apr 19, 2021
10:05:17am

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

But obviously it just doesn't happen.

Report problem with this ad

Indy Coug

Bio page: Indy Coug
Joined: Dec 20, 2001
Last login: Jun 8, 2024
Total posts: 185,400 (9,870 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Would you consider Wilson's season "inconsistent with flashes of brilliance"?

ochobeeguy

4/19/21 9:54am

Absolutely no. This is how you know you can disregard whatever this writer says about anything

YIsForBrigham

4/19/21 9:56am

He also has Mac Jones 5th QB at #14, and Parsons from Penn St at #15.

ochobeeguy

4/19/21 10:03am

Also the fact he's employeed by Yahoo

molodyets

4/19/21 10:12am

Yahoo's still around. Wow.

Benfica1

4/19/21 10:18am

2020? LOL no

CommodoreCoug

4/19/21 9:58am

2019 absolutely, but describing his 2020 season like that is asinine

ZacSeljaas'Stache

4/19/21 10:00am

Yep, previous seasons he was inconsistent but we saw the talent.

mudpupper

4/19/21 10:04am

I truly believe the excuse that his shoulder was jacked up in 2019.

RdF3

4/19/21 10:06am

The easy response to criticisms of Wilson and BYU's schedule:

Gustav

4/19/21 10:01am

If there were a bunch of G5 QBs putting up 200 efficiencies against G5 teams, then they might have a point

Indy Coug

4/19/21 10:05am

That's conflating multiple years of play with his 12 most recent games

Indy Coug

4/19/21 10:04am

If you take his whole career, there is some truth. But "flashes of brilliance" is an understatement

Adrielle

4/19/21 10:04am

if "inconsistent" means brilliance in every game of the season, then YES.

Avery

4/19/21 10:08am

Maybe that is it. Inconsistently bad.

ochobeeguy

4/19/21 11:10am

Nope. 2019 was solid with flashes of inconsistency.

Benfica1

4/19/21 10:11am

I get some of the critiques from analysts outside the BYU loop. They're not

ldssdl

4/19/21 10:19am

His 2020 passes were consistently on-target and on-a-rope more so than I have

mwcoug

4/19/21 10:19am

Analysis aside, I really like how his mock goes. It makes a lot of sense

Alpi Gusto

4/19/21 10:34am

Unfortunately this won't be able to be disputed until 2 years into his pro caree

BYU Grounds

4/19/21 10:48am

I think we can dispute today that he had one of the most consistent years ever.

ochobeeguy

4/19/21 11:10am

Journalism in all topics now suffers from using the Internet as a source.

ochobeeguy

4/19/21 11:08am

Here's Wilson's passing efficiency rating (PER) against opponents defensive passing efficiency.

SpiffCoug

4/19/21 11:12am

Season!?!?! No... Career? Absolutely...

canndyman

4/19/21 11:49am

journalists are scum, sports journos only slightly less so than political

GeraldGarner

4/19/21 1:42pm

Pretty broad stroke there, big guy

Alpi Gusto

4/19/21 1:52pm

The advantage of having a lot of of info is being able to make generalizations

GeraldGarner

4/19/21 2:10pm

Consistently brilliant with flashes of being mortal

KingDave

4/19/21 1:58pm

As a career, yes.

vandalcoug

4/19/21 2:07pm

But if your whole last year is great, there is no longer inconsistency.

ochobeeguy

4/19/21 3:14pm

RE: Would you consider Wilson's season "inconsistent with flashes of

mattpatt

4/19/21 4:02pm

I can think of at least 20 people who went there just today.

ochobeeguy

4/19/21 4:21pm

(I know I did).

Benfica1

4/19/21 7:09pm

Fields is "easily the 2nd best quarterback in the class", yet rated #3

Hill4Heisman

4/19/21 4:14pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad