Based on NCAA records, hard to argue against Jim McMahon.

Report problem with this ad

Jun 22, 2022
4:49:32pm

Cougar Jazz Fan All-American

Report problem with this ad

Cougar Jazz Fan

Bio page: Cougar Jazz Fan
Joined: Jan 3, 2002
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 17,366 (894 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Who is the BYU GOAT athlete. All sports, but only BYU collegiate career.

snowbird

6/22/22 4:37pm

Danny Ainge

CopperLix

6/22/22 4:38pm

Played MLB for the Blue Jays while at BYU.

Ragnar Danneskjold

6/22/22 4:41pm

Goat athlete is Danny Ainge and it isn’t close.

Scrog

6/22/22 6:38pm

see my post below

Canusa

6/22/22 7:04pm

Based on NCAA records, hard to argue against Jim McMahon.

Cougar Jazz Fan

6/22/22 4:49pm

Shauna Rohbock, Taysom Hill (what could have been without injury), Ainge

Iman23

6/22/22 4:53pm

<< Deleted >>

Turnpike Lane

6/22/22 5:05pm

Im going with the one that won a heisman

boctabulous

6/22/22 5:41pm

I want to say Ainge, McMahon, or Detmer, but the guy who won a NC has a case.

ReiUrso

6/22/22 5:43pm

Except for all his teammates who also won a NC.

boctabulous

6/22/22 5:45pm

That's the case for any of them. He's the leader of the national champion.

ReiUrso

6/22/22 5:49pm

Actually none of Detmers teammates won a heisman. All of boscoes teammates won

boctabulous

6/22/22 5:53pm

GOAT athlete? It's Taysom

TNT

6/22/22 5:46pm

Do his injuries factor into athleticism?

SUAVO

6/22/22 6:09pm

Doug Howard was star in basketball and baseball.

Bluforever

6/22/22 5:58pm

Tiffany Lott.

CougGolf

6/22/22 6:05pm

Courtney Wayment

CougGolf

6/22/22 6:06pm

Sorry but there is only one: Ainge

Canusa

6/22/22 6:22pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad