Cinci had a big win against #5 Notre Dame, They also beat #20 Houston for a 2nd quality win.
If BYU went undefeated, their best wins would be against #21 8-4 Oregon and (NR) 7-5 Notre Dame.
In addition Cincinatti was the only undefeated team left, in 2022 there are 2 undefeated teams.
But the real question has nothing to do with Cinci. The one question is simple. Does a CFP comittee put a 12-0 BYU in the CFP ahead of a 11-1 Ohio State?