My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
You don't have the ability to post right now...
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 25, 2016
4:25
:28
pm
IronPotato
Walk-on
DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the following
positions, who would you pick?
QB -
RB -
WR -
TE -
OL -
S -
CB -
LB -
DL -
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
IronPotato
Previous username
Ajardine
Bio page
IronPotato
Joined
Sep 27, 2014
Last login
Jun 6, 2024
Total posts
5,333 (2 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Related Threads
Children:
RE: Collie
(credfern84, Oct 26, 2016 at 10:17am)
Messages
Author
Time
DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the following
IronPotato
10/25/16 4:25pm
Pitta is my TE. McTyer and Morgan are my corners.
Crush4
10/25/16 4:29pm
Here's mine...
IronPotato
10/25/16 4:34pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
ManicBlue
10/25/16 4:42pm
Very similar list
CougarVikingSeaSider
10/25/16 8:38pm
Anybody remember Jay Miller from the 70s? Many diving catches. Rare talent these
SJBLUE
10/26/16 3:11pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
Katewot
10/25/16 4:44pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the following
foofcoug
10/25/16 4:50pm
Bronco Mendenhall's list
FoneyBuller
10/25/16 5:34pm
I second this list but swap out Rodney Rice for McTyer
fulano
10/25/16 6:07pm
Agree on all but Willis. I would have taken Jenkins
GhostOf84
10/25/16 8:02pm
Same, except Staley for Willis, and maybe Derwin Gray for Holmoe.
Loon to the Moon
10/25/16 10:25pm
Any list that has any RB other than Williams or Staley should be disqualified.
Horacio Caine
10/26/16 3:39am
RE: Any list that has any RB other than Williams or Staley should be disqualified.
foofcoug
10/26/16 7:40am
Willis, WAC. Williams, 5 or more top tier foes per year.
jkccoug
10/26/16 12:43pm
I'm not knocking Williams, he's a great back. But to say that Willis isn't in Williams' or Staley's league is just dumb.
foofcoug
10/26/16 12:47pm
Fair point. A lot of youngsters here don't even remember Willis or Heimuli or
jkccoug
10/26/16 12:52pm
Willis was in the NFL. His competition is irrelevant.
macaroni
10/27/16 3:20pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
cougarmanguy
10/25/16 4:51pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
Casey Jones
10/25/16 5:00pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
Belboz
10/25/16 5:01pm
Our current team.
LaVellIfIKnow
10/25/16 5:06pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
flyusaf
10/25/16 5:08pm
Young, Williams, Collie, Lewis, Elewonibi, Morrell, McTyer, Morris, Buck
Tygger
10/25/16 5:14pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
The Maestro
10/25/16 5:24pm
This post trancended regency bias into, like, future bias?
mvtoro
10/25/16 7:50pm
But really though, Dayan Lake? He's our 3rd option, and will be behind Troy...
Dissenter
10/26/16 12:40pm
Dayan lake is not 3rd option. Did you watch the Boise game?
The Maestro
10/26/16 5:16pm
Yes
The Maestro
10/26/16 1:52pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
DB Cooper
10/25/16 5:30pm
pretty good list.
Tuskaloosa Cougar
10/25/16 6:20pm
My list:
Graig Swame
10/25/16 6:24pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
CopperLix
10/25/16 7:06pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
TheDeek
10/25/16 7:20pm
I'm not sure how everyone else missed all of these. Wow!
Kougrage
10/25/16 7:31pm
Detmer, Staley, Collie, Lewis, Tait, Sorensen, McTyer, Morris, Buck
mosterlow
10/25/16 8:04pm
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the following
46in96
10/25/16 8:08pm
You just broke all the rules. ONE, not two
youngster
10/25/16 8:12pm
I'm a rule breaker. Don't know what to tell ya.
46in96
10/25/16 8:15pm
I like that someone remembered Muirbrook - he was awesome, but so was Unga - too
jaba166
10/26/16 3:10am
I can't believe it took that many posts for someone to pick Shay Muirbrook as LB
michacoug
10/26/16 9:04am
I'd give Morris the edge since he was bigger and a little more gifted
Ulysses14
10/26/16 9:08am
I like Nacua as much as the next guy but Rich was much better.
bbqelitist
10/25/16 8:30pm
Rich was great, this was a hard one for me. I think I'm swayed by his INT #s.
IronPotato
10/25/16 8:31pm
What are the main differences between Nacua, Rich, and Francisco?
IronPotato
10/25/16 8:33pm
McMahon for all positions.
OliverGranger
10/25/16 8:59pm
McMahon, Williams, Collie, Pitta, Eliwonibi,Morrell, McTyer, Leon White, Ansah.
jvquarterback
10/25/16 9:24pm
Detmer, Staley, Collie, Pitta, Tait, Sorenson, Morrell, McTyer, Morris, Ansah
mcrsj
10/25/16 9:50pm
Love Nacua, but too little love for Andrew Rich on this list. Our secondary is
Seaward
10/25/16 9:51pm
Detmer, Staley, Collie, Pitta, Tait, Francisco, Morgan, Muirbrook, Buck
fredgarvin
10/25/16 10:28pm
Collie has to get the nod for the most dominant WR we've ever had, but
jaba166
10/26/16 3:19am
Collie isn't most dominant. He was great but over rated on this list. Drage is
Horacio Caine
10/26/16 3:32am
Mark Bellini was no slouch, but Phil
deljdc
10/26/16 8:38am
I'd take Koz (when healthy) over Bellini.
Loon to the Moon
10/26/16 9:19am
Bellini was a RB but has awesome hands....great player
BYU4eVeR
10/26/16 10:48am
You're thinking of Matt Bellini. Mark was a WR.
Loon to the Moon
10/26/16 11:27am
I swore I put Matt, not Mark on there.
deljdc
10/26/16 12:37pm
Collie did better against TCU than you think, and he was better in every way than Drage or Hoffman. Hoffman...
BengalCougar
10/26/16 4:25pm
Collie played against TCU twice, he had more than 100 yards receiving in both games. Hoffman also played them twice...
BengalCougar
10/26/16 4:37pm
My top three would be Collie, Kozlowski, and Drage
fredgarvin
10/26/16 9:40am
I love Drage too, ran great routes, and great possession guy, but played in a
jaba166
10/27/16 5:06am
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
Mot
10/25/16 11:09pm
It's pretty amazing that we've never had a dominant WR or DB
Ulysses14
10/26/16 4:44am
I would say Collie was.
CougarBreath
10/26/16 1:03pm
McMahon, Staley, Colley, Mili, Tait, Sorenson, Morgan, Van Noy, Ansah
PJMort
10/26/16 8:38am
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
gww687
10/26/16 9:42am
RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the
moosebuckle
10/26/16 10:29am
Is it the offseason already?
Coop
10/26/16 12:09pm
Mine
ALC
10/26/16 12:53pm
McMahon, JW, Hoffman/KO, Pitta, Tait, Morgan, McTyer, Morris, Ziggy!
Ash
10/26/16 1:23pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad