I'm not knocking Williams, he's a great back. But to say that Willis isn't in Williams' or Staley's league is just dumb.

You don't have the ability to post right now...

Oct 26, 2016
12:47:36pm

foofcoug All-American

Report problem with this ad

foofcoug

Bio page: foofcoug
Joined: Jul 7, 2004
Last login: Jun 16, 2024
Total posts: 134,193 (49,354 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the following

IronPotato

10/25/16 4:25pm

Pitta is my TE. McTyer and Morgan are my corners.

Crush4

10/25/16 4:29pm

Here's mine...

IronPotato

10/25/16 4:34pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

ManicBlue

10/25/16 4:42pm

Very similar list

CougarVikingSeaSider

10/25/16 8:38pm

Anybody remember Jay Miller from the 70s? Many diving catches. Rare talent these

SJBLUE

10/26/16 3:11pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

Katewot

10/25/16 4:44pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the following

foofcoug

10/25/16 4:50pm

Bronco Mendenhall's list

FoneyBuller

10/25/16 5:34pm

I second this list but swap out Rodney Rice for McTyer

fulano

10/25/16 6:07pm

Agree on all but Willis. I would have taken Jenkins

GhostOf84

10/25/16 8:02pm

Same, except Staley for Willis, and maybe Derwin Gray for Holmoe.

Loon to the Moon

10/25/16 10:25pm

Any list that has any RB other than Williams or Staley should be disqualified.

Horacio Caine

10/26/16 3:39am

RE: Any list that has any RB other than Williams or Staley should be disqualified.

foofcoug

10/26/16 7:40am

Willis, WAC. Williams, 5 or more top tier foes per year.

jkccoug

10/26/16 12:43pm

I'm not knocking Williams, he's a great back. But to say that Willis isn't in Williams' or Staley's league is just dumb.

foofcoug

10/26/16 12:47pm

Fair point. A lot of youngsters here don't even remember Willis or Heimuli or

jkccoug

10/26/16 12:52pm

Willis was in the NFL. His competition is irrelevant.

macaroni

10/27/16 3:20pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

cougarmanguy

10/25/16 4:51pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

Casey Jones

10/25/16 5:00pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

Belboz

10/25/16 5:01pm

Our current team.

LaVellIfIKnow

10/25/16 5:06pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

flyusaf

10/25/16 5:08pm

Young, Williams, Collie, Lewis, Elewonibi, Morrell, McTyer, Morris, Buck

Tygger

10/25/16 5:14pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

The Maestro

10/25/16 5:24pm

This post trancended regency bias into, like, future bias?

mvtoro

10/25/16 7:50pm

But really though, Dayan Lake? He's our 3rd option, and will be behind Troy...

Dissenter

10/26/16 12:40pm

Dayan lake is not 3rd option. Did you watch the Boise game?

The Maestro

10/26/16 5:16pm

Yes

The Maestro

10/26/16 1:52pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

DB Cooper

10/25/16 5:30pm

pretty good list.

Tuskaloosa Cougar

10/25/16 6:20pm

My list:

Graig Swame

10/25/16 6:24pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

CopperLix

10/25/16 7:06pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

TheDeek

10/25/16 7:20pm

I'm not sure how everyone else missed all of these. Wow!

Kougrage

10/25/16 7:31pm

Detmer, Staley, Collie, Lewis, Tait, Sorensen, McTyer, Morris, Buck

mosterlow

10/25/16 8:04pm

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the following

46in96

10/25/16 8:08pm

You just broke all the rules. ONE, not two

youngster

10/25/16 8:12pm

I'm a rule breaker. Don't know what to tell ya.

46in96

10/25/16 8:15pm

I like that someone remembered Muirbrook - he was awesome, but so was Unga - too

jaba166

10/26/16 3:10am

I can't believe it took that many posts for someone to pick Shay Muirbrook as LB

michacoug

10/26/16 9:04am

I'd give Morris the edge since he was bigger and a little more gifted

Ulysses14

10/26/16 9:08am

I like Nacua as much as the next guy but Rich was much better.

bbqelitist

10/25/16 8:30pm

Rich was great, this was a hard one for me. I think I'm swayed by his INT #s.

IronPotato

10/25/16 8:31pm

What are the main differences between Nacua, Rich, and Francisco?

IronPotato

10/25/16 8:33pm

McMahon for all positions.

OliverGranger

10/25/16 8:59pm

McMahon, Williams, Collie, Pitta, Eliwonibi,Morrell, McTyer, Leon White, Ansah.

jvquarterback

10/25/16 9:24pm

Detmer, Staley, Collie, Pitta, Tait, Sorenson, Morrell, McTyer, Morris, Ansah

mcrsj

10/25/16 9:50pm

Love Nacua, but too little love for Andrew Rich on this list. Our secondary is

Seaward

10/25/16 9:51pm

Detmer, Staley, Collie, Pitta, Tait, Francisco, Morgan, Muirbrook, Buck

fredgarvin

10/25/16 10:28pm

Collie has to get the nod for the most dominant WR we've ever had, but

jaba166

10/26/16 3:19am

Collie isn't most dominant. He was great but over rated on this list. Drage is

Horacio Caine

10/26/16 3:32am

Mark Bellini was no slouch, but Phil

deljdc

10/26/16 8:38am

I'd take Koz (when healthy) over Bellini.

Loon to the Moon

10/26/16 9:19am

Bellini was a RB but has awesome hands....great player

BYU4eVeR

10/26/16 10:48am

You're thinking of Matt Bellini. Mark was a WR.

Loon to the Moon

10/26/16 11:27am

I swore I put Matt, not Mark on there.

deljdc

10/26/16 12:37pm

Collie did better against TCU than you think, and he was better in every way than Drage or Hoffman. Hoffman...

BengalCougar

10/26/16 4:25pm

Collie played against TCU twice, he had more than 100 yards receiving in both games. Hoffman also played them twice...

BengalCougar

10/26/16 4:37pm

My top three would be Collie, Kozlowski, and Drage

fredgarvin

10/26/16 9:40am

I love Drage too, ran great routes, and great possession guy, but played in a

jaba166

10/27/16 5:06am

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

Mot

10/25/16 11:09pm

It's pretty amazing that we've never had a dominant WR or DB

Ulysses14

10/26/16 4:44am

I would say Collie was.

CougarBreath

10/26/16 1:03pm

McMahon, Staley, Colley, Mili, Tait, Sorenson, Morgan, Van Noy, Ansah

PJMort

10/26/16 8:38am

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

gww687

10/26/16 9:42am

RE: DREAM TEAM: If you could pick just one player in BYU history for the

moosebuckle

10/26/16 10:29am

Is it the offseason already?

Coop

10/26/16 12:09pm

Mine

ALC

10/26/16 12:53pm

McMahon, JW, Hoffman/KO, Pitta, Tait, Morgan, McTyer, Morris, Ziggy!

Posting on CougarBoard