My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 3, 2017
5:25
:11
pm
thebruce
Playmaker
It's a valid critique until they prove otherwise.
If a coach doesn't have a proven track record there is nothing to suggest he is any better than his current teams performance.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
thebruce
New username
JoeExotic
Bio page
thebruce
Joined
Jul 19, 2014
Last login
Mar 27, 2020
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
WHY ARE YOU ALL ARE SO QUICK TO BLAME DETMER?
bluecool5
9/3/17 5:12pm
After 2 QBs, it does get a little worrisome, but I agree it may be too early to
westsidecoug
9/3/17 5:15pm
Lol
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:15pm
He gets the blame because he owns the offense. When it becomes a good offense we
coastcat
9/3/17 8:29pm
Yep
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 9:28pm
I am not off the Detmer wagon, but is it possible to know the offense better
Bob Vance
9/3/17 5:16pm
Detmer lacks experience as a college coach.
HangookCoug
9/3/17 5:16pm
I'm sick of hearing lack of experience. No starts as a college coach.
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:19pm
No one*
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:19pm
Yes, Detmer is overqualified. Give me a break.
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:22pm
Never seen his heisman, wish I had though!
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:24pm
Detmer was not and is not overqualified to be a college OC.
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:26pm
RE: Detmer was not and is not overqualified to be a college OC.
bluecool5
9/3/17 6:11pm
Funny, because if any poster could be accused of being a coach's family member, it's you
SJS
9/3/17 6:13pm
RE: Funny, because if any poster could be accused of being a coach's family
bluecool5
9/3/17 6:15pm
Can't handle facts. Resorts to name calling and put downs.
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 6:44pm
Name calling?
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 6:51pm
A put down. No legitimate argument left
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 6:54pm
Good you base your opinion on opinions of others.
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:27pm
Sounds good to me. Now get your prescription checked.
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:34pm
Almost now one gets to be an oc without college coaching experience
cougarfann888
9/3/17 9:02pm
RE: Detmer lacks experience as a college coach.
bluecool5
9/3/17 5:20pm
Yet, it appears to be valid.
HangookCoug
9/3/17 5:22pm
No, it's a fact, not a critique.
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:23pm
I'm sorry hawk! I forgot you football background! Where did you play/coach again
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:26pm
You can't handle facts.
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:32pm
RE: No, it's a fact, not a critique.
bluecool5
9/3/17 5:26pm
It's a valid critique until they prove otherwise.
thebruce
9/3/17 5:25pm
There is not many NFL or College OCs willing to come to BYU.
Jay_L
9/3/17 5:25pm
Correct!!!
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:27pm
Should come from FCS or lesser G5 programs, or impressive position coaches
keylimesoda
9/3/17 5:27pm
Exactly
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:38pm
And you know this how?
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:34pm
What does it matter I know? You tell me.
Jay_L
9/3/17 5:46pm
You made an assertion. I want to know if you have something to back it up.
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:55pm
Never been on the Detmer bandwagon
keylimesoda
9/3/17 5:26pm
Some people just don't get it! I forget the qualified ones like to school us.
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:28pm
This argument is lame and not legitimate...
Hawk Talons
9/3/17 5:40pm
NOT we..... YOU!
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:43pm
RE: This argument is lame and not legitimate...
bluecool5
9/3/17 5:45pm
I've never made a movie, but I can tell a good one from a bad one
keylimesoda
9/3/17 11:09pm
Funny, bad movie to you, great to someone else
B2daY2daU
9/4/17 6:04am
RE: Never been on the Detmer bandwagon
bluecool5
9/3/17 5:31pm
if he's so good then why haven't the results been there so far?
Cougs 96-97
9/3/17 5:45pm
One reason!!! Lack of Talent!!!
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:50pm
Then why did we look bad against Portland State?
keylimesoda
9/3/17 11:07pm
Exactly LACK OF TALENT!!' You either got it or you don't.
B2daY2daU
9/4/17 6:06am
RE: if he's so good then why haven't the results been there so far?
bluecool5
9/3/17 5:51pm
So it's all the player's fault? Got it.
SJS
9/3/17 6:02pm
RE: So it's all the player's fault? Got it.
bluecool5
9/3/17 6:05pm
Please link to posts saying it's 100% Detmer's fault
SJS
9/3/17 6:08pm
RE: Please link to posts saying it's 100% Detmer's fault
bluecool5
9/3/17 6:17pm
And yet... you can't link one
SJS
9/3/17 6:29pm
For me to many to link. Just google Detmer's name you'll see it.
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 6:35pm
RE: For me to many to link. Just google Detmer's name you'll see it.
SJS
9/3/17 6:37pm
😂😂😂then you'll just not see it I guess
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 6:44pm
I'm sorry, I forgot who was playing the game and throwing the passes
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 6:06pm
RE: I'm sorry, I forgot who was playing the game and throwing the passes
SJS
9/3/17 6:10pm
RE: I'm sorry, I forgot who was playing the game and throwing the passes
bluecool5
9/3/17 6:18pm
I think it is a playing tight/afraid to make mistakes issues not a scheme issue.
BYUtka
9/3/17 5:32pm
RE: I think it is a playing tight/afraid to make mistakes issues not a scheme
bluecool5
9/3/17 5:35pm
I agree!!!
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 5:37pm
Long reply if interested
byuborn
9/3/17 6:48pm
Thoughtful response. Thanks for sharing.
Dwreck
9/3/17 6:54pm
Kalani not Silani.
eddog
9/3/17 7:58pm
Results have not been good.
wilsdad
9/3/17 7:37pm
Hill looks better after dropping weight and not trying to lift like someone on
GilbertAZCougar
9/3/17 7:58pm
Position coaching...
wilsdad
9/4/17 8:02am
A few Yewt trolls on this thread I believe.
Rocketman
9/3/17 7:56pm
Understanding football & calling the right plays at the right time are different
BYUfan92
9/3/17 9:33pm
So are throwing up a prayer and being accurate.
B2daY2daU
9/3/17 9:39pm
First off - everyone you just quoted was a pro player
gww687
9/3/17 9:48pm
Detmer is running Norm Chow's offense which hasn't worked since 2005.
Bobmarleyjr
9/3/17 10:11pm
Michael Jordan was a smart basketball player.
thebruce
9/3/17 10:44pm
None of those guys listed were "coached" by Detmer. Mentored? Sure. Big difference.
SlantRoute
9/3/17 10:48pm
Further, those guys didn't run offenses designed by Ty. He just helped them understand Xs and Os a little better.
SlantRoute
9/3/17 10:51pm
I meant to thumbs up your post. Not thumbs down
thebruce
9/3/17 11:03pm
When you're the OC you get the heat. Happens at every level
Deuceman
9/3/17 10:56pm
LSU and Penn St switched to spread last year and started scoring and winning
Bobmarleyjr
9/4/17 12:08am
They also have talented athletes. No matter what offense you run, mangum has
B2daY2daU
9/4/17 6:09am
Could another OC find a way to be better with the athletes we have?
keylimesoda
9/4/17 11:48am
Probably get the same results. You have to make the plays to get results
B2daY2daU
9/4/17 11:57am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad