I'm afraid stars matter if it looks like the last 2 elite 11s couldn't develop

Aug 27, 2018
12:56:59pm

Hoss Bonaventure Contributor

here at byu. You're right it may not matter that much practically, but I worry about perception. If Wilson develops into something great than I think we're good.

Report problem with this ad

Hoss Bonaventure

Bio page: Hoss Bonaventure
Joined: Dec 20, 2015
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 1,148 (12 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Either Tanner has improved, or all the QBs suck. It's as simple as that.

Left Shark Coug

8/27/18 12:32pm

You have a coaching staff that is under the gun after a 4-9 season with fans (and possibly admin) breathing

Indy Coug

8/27/18 12:35pm

Well said

Mexicougazul

8/27/18 12:36pm

Even if that chance, based on past production, isn’t very good.

Gerald-DeGroot

8/27/18 1:24pm

Tanner didn't stink last year in fall camp

kimdaddy35

8/27/18 12:36pm

That spring game, though.

SandYFan

8/27/18 12:37pm

I think the disparity between practice and games last year is the main reason they went live so much

Indy Coug

8/27/18 12:38pm

I agree

kimdaddy35

8/27/18 12:43pm

I'd love to know what the truth was. Sometimes coaches see what they want to

Left Shark Coug

8/27/18 12:42pm

It wasn't just the coaches. The media were gushing over tanner and the offense.

rggee

8/27/18 12:45pm

If the defense is abysmal, then that is meaningless. See 2017.

SandYFan

8/27/18 12:45pm

Yes, much of it was one of the worst passing defenses in the entire country

kimdaddy35

8/27/18 12:48pm

Half the media covering BYU would gush over a butterfly.

Left Shark Coug

8/27/18 12:49pm

Camp mean next to nothing.

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/27/18 3:00pm

I also think we can't have another 4* QB recruit not produce here. We need to

Hoss Bonaventure

8/27/18 12:48pm

See I don't think stars have anything to do with it. I agree we need to develop

kimdaddy35

8/27/18 12:50pm

I'm afraid stars matter if it looks like the last 2 elite 11s couldn't develop

Hoss Bonaventure

8/27/18 12:56pm

Despite going 4-9 last year we received a commitment from one of the best

kimdaddy35

8/27/18 12:59pm

Each player was coached by a different guy. Not an indictment on this staff.

jpal1397

8/27/18 1:11pm

Can't really call Mangum a flop until after this year IMO

BYUFootballisBack

8/27/18 2:44pm

System changes everything.

Adwight

8/27/18 12:59pm

This^^^^^^^!!!!

joesemenoff

8/27/18 2:20pm

I remember Kalani pregame PSU...

MonroviaG

8/27/18 1:12pm

If Sitake has the stones to fire Detmer, then he'd have no problem

Ned Schneebly

8/27/18 2:43pm

I’m going with the latter.

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/27/18 3:01pm

I think it was very close and they chose to bet on experience.

Cougstreak

8/27/18 3:13pm

Tanner in practice does not equal Tanner facing a live rush.

Bostonblue

8/27/18 3:41pm

This is reality. Will never understand why so many fans can’t see this.

Gerald-DeGroot

8/27/18 5:59pm

Then he'll quickly be replaced. Neither Kalani nor Grimes have time for a QB

Left Shark Coug

8/27/18 6:20pm

There were plenty of reports that he was looking really good in fall camp

Posting on CougarBoard