I’m okay with Mo and Jeter. And when CC goes in as a Yankee part of me will break.

Report problem with this ad

Jul 19, 2019
4:15:06pm

shimmy The books were better.

Report problem with this ad

shimmy

Previous username: AFCoug83
Bio page: shimmy
Joined: Jan 15, 2008
Last login: Jun 2, 2024
Total posts: 117,835 (37,124 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Should Barry Bonds be in the Hall of Fame?

Mr. Belding The easy way out

7/19/19 3:02pm

If Pete Rose isn't eligible, Bonds (and all juicers) shouldn't be either

Frank Castiglione

7/19/19 3:03pm

Problem is, how do we know who juiced and who didn't.

Cobra Cougar

7/19/19 3:11pm

most of the league was juicing. Bonds just separated himself from the rest

archie

7/19/19 3:13pm

because he was a better player than they all were.

mcnasty

7/19/19 3:30pm

If they get caught, they get held accountable

Frank Castiglione

7/19/19 3:15pm

I agree, but the hall of fame is a weird form of enforcing punishment.

shimmy

7/19/19 3:30pm

I can agree with that. That's why the Pete Rose thing bugs me

Frank Castiglione

7/19/19 3:39pm

Agreed. Let them all in. Go ahead and let them make a speech and point out their flaws.

shimmy

7/19/19 3:43pm

Throw in Yankees from the past 20-30 years, and I'm on board with ya

Frank Castiglione

7/19/19 3:54pm

I’m okay with Mo and Jeter. And when CC goes in as a Yankee part of me will break.

shimmy

7/19/19 4:15pm

Unpopular opinion: Rose’s baseball sins are worse than PEDs.

garyfan

7/19/19 4:33pm

One of the best players to play the game ever. He was so good even before juice

archie

7/19/19 3:14pm

It's to bad, I think both him and ARod could have been in that conversation

RC Vikings

7/19/19 3:38pm

Where is the option for I don't care?

kimdaddy35

7/19/19 3:17pm

Yes and so should the other juicers. And Pete Rose.

LaVellIfIKnow

7/19/19 3:23pm

McGuire/Sosa home run race revived baseball

cougarfann888

7/19/19 3:36pm

No, but I think baseball needs a Hall of Shame...

530Coug

7/19/19 4:23pm

Yes, because I have a bunch of his baseball cards

2FarGone

7/19/19 5:13pm

Voting him in would send the wrong message about the ends justifying the means.

NorCal Cougar

7/19/19 8:22pm

Pete Rose should be in HOF too!

Posting on CougarBoard