My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jan 27, 2021
9:30
:33
pm
Elvis
All-American
Here's the data:
SInce 2011, He has reffed 17 games. We are 9-8 including 2 wins over Utah and one over USU. However, we are 0-3 v SDSU when he refs and )-1 against Gonzaga and 0-1 against St Mary's
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Elvis
Bio page
Elvis
Joined
Mar 9, 2001
Last login
Jun 7, 2024
Total posts
3,451 (27 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Posted without comment.
Niiineteeen84
1/27/21 8:09pm
What other games has he officiated?
ldssdl
1/27/21 8:25pm
He allowed SDSU to tackle Tyler Haws at the end of regulation in Maui a few years back.
slatecoug
1/27/21 10:51pm
I knew we were in big trouble when I saw him
aaronmania
1/27/21 8:39pm
Seems like data should be available on this. Anyone know where it could be found to prove/disprove this hypothesis?
Greg Kite's 'stache
1/27/21 9:08pm
This! Someone who likes spending time on this crap make it happen!
ColonelMustard
1/28/21 4:03pm
Here's the data:
Elvis
1/27/21 9:30pm
Source?
ldssdl
1/27/21 9:37pm
Well, that would seem to indicate that the assertion made isn't accurate. Funny what happens when you use actual data.
Greg Kite's 'stache
1/27/21 9:57pm
Except all you have to do is go back and watch the end of the game against SDSU in Maui
slatecoug
1/27/21 10:54pm
The statement by Jay Drew is “I can't remember a game that Randy McCall officiated that BYU won”
Greg Kite's 'stache
1/27/21 11:19pm
There's nothing wrong with Drew's statement. He didn't say "in the research I'v
wiscougarfan
1/28/21 6:31am
it's not a definitive rejection of Drew's assertion. He said "I can't recall..."
icecougar
1/28/21 12:11pm
That's because McCall has had some really bad late game officiating performances in games BYU has played.
slatecoug
1/28/21 2:25pm
Good take. Just because byu has won 50% means nothing. It’s not like a ref can
ColonelMustard
1/28/21 4:05pm
So Drew's statement was about his poor memory, not about biased officiating.
ptcougr
1/28/21 4:23am
However, those stats DO suggest it makes a negative difference when he refs.
jkccoug
1/28/21 3:58pm
What did the advanced metrics/Vegas lines say SHOULD have been our record?
jkccoug
1/28/21 3:50pm
Our overall win % during that timeframe is 68%. But only 53% with that ref, so
jkccoug
1/28/21 3:56pm
Just because byu has won with him on the floor means nothing
ColonelMustard
1/28/21 4:07pm
Seems like our record in close games with him reffing would be more telling.
byuinva
1/28/21 4:18pm
I went back and looked up game reports...
Elvis
1/27/21 10:25pm
that one series near the end where they had over the back, a charge, was
bald man
1/28/21 5:20am
Would be fun to get the advanced metrics and point spreads and compare BYU's
jkccoug
1/28/21 3:48pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad