https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=26290673
Basically BYU's class rankings have gone down, and while the average recruit rating has gone up, it hasn't done so as fast as recruit ratings have inflated.
Basically, we've got a job making $60k a year and are arguing we're more successful than our grandfather who only made $50k a year when he worked 40 years ago. Can't necessarily blame it all on independence, but it's inarguable that we have had a steady decline in recruiting since going independent.