My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 22, 2014
8:23
:42
am
runnincoug
It just seems petty to say, "Fire the coach because, er, he doesn't love me"
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
runnincoug
Bio page
runnincoug
Joined
May 26, 2011
Last login
Jun 18, 2024
Total posts
33,969 (2,623 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Why are fans giving Dave Rose a pass?
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:07am
because he is not Bronco. And very few fan bases can hate both FB & BB coaches.
BlueFrog
10/22/14 8:08am
<< Deleted >>
Acorn
10/22/14 8:24am
You're putting the cart before the horse, it's football season. Let's cross that
CougarBuckeye-BYUI
10/22/14 9:22am
You're not going to convince anyone of Bronco's greatness by bashing Rose
BlueK
10/22/14 8:09am
I'm not saying Bronco's great or Rose is lame. I'm saying they're the same
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:10am
Yes you are
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:14am
You missed "I'm actually strongly on the Dave Rose bandwagon...
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:25am
Saying that after running down his major accomplishments and exagerrating his
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:33am
welcome to Bronco's life on CB!
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:35am
I dont think those who have gone after Bronco have turned around and proclaimed
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:43am
the sports are not the same, so good comparisons are not really possible
BlueK
10/22/14 8:14am
Because basketball isn't football.
IGlowInTheDark
10/22/14 8:10am
Great logic … but how is it really that different? Is losing to Loyola
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:13am
In basketball you can lose to the worst team in the country...
IGlowInTheDark
10/22/14 8:14am
not only that, but the nature of the game is different and makes those kinds of
BlueK
10/22/14 8:18am
So the lack of a football inclusive playoff means Bronco is a worse coach?
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:20am
The best way I can sum up your comparison is like this:
IGlowInTheDark
10/22/14 8:21am
The Jimmer season bought Rose more time. Bronco hasn't had a season like that
Walter Bellhaven
10/22/14 8:11am
This would have been Bronco's Jimmer season if Taysom hadn't been injured
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:14am
That is what happens when you base your success on a running QB with
Walter Bellhaven
10/22/14 8:17am
Very true! I think we all knew it was only a matter of time he could potentially
Chazz Reinhold
10/22/14 8:25am
You're right. It was dumb of Rose to put all of his eggs and shot attempts in
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:27am
Is that an accurate comparison? Be honest.
Walter Bellhaven
10/22/14 8:29am
All that shooting may have worn out Jimmer's arm. Just as predictable as a
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:45am
My point is all of Rose's eggs were in that one basket, as evidenced by
runnincoug
10/22/14 9:51am
But there is far less chance that that fails than a running QB
Walter Bellhaven
10/22/14 10:13am
Sure, I agree with everything you said. My main point is that the Jimmer team
runnincoug
10/22/14 11:23am
Rose has plenty of critics on this board
concolor couguar
10/22/14 11:25am
Re: Rose doesn't have the benefit of a Lavell Edwards who came in, won a NC
Schultz is back
10/22/14 8:22am
To be honest, I think he has done a pretty poor job as of late.
thebruce
10/22/14 8:12am
also, even if we had Taysom, our team still wouldn't be a legit top 10 team.
thebruce
10/22/14 8:16am
Rose's defense was a train wreck too that year, and Bronco has beaten Texas
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:18am
his defense was solid that year. Jackson, KC, Abouo, Hartsock, and even Davies
thebruce
10/22/14 8:29am
Defense was top 3 in the conference if you consider pace
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:30am
Wait are you talking 2011? or last year?
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:31am
You're right, I got my years mixed up. It was after that year that D went down
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:36am
I was referring to the defense last year. It was average last year given pace
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:42am
Fire Dave Rose!
Blueto
10/22/14 8:12am
1. Rose is more personally like-able than Bronco.
shoganai
10/22/14 8:14am
I really think this is it…if we admit it, it's just because Rose is easier to
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:17am
If this was Bronco's first chance at a "Jimmer" season then you'd have a point.
shoganai
10/22/14 8:22am
It just seems petty to say, "Fire the coach because, er, he doesn't love me"
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:23am
That does seem petty. Who said that?
shoganai
10/22/14 8:24am
If you admit that we don't like Bronco because of his personality instead of
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:26am
Very few people on CB want to fire Bronco.
shoganai
10/22/14 8:30am
They did a poll on this. I actually think it's like 50/50, and the 50% wanting
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:31am
I don't think it's 50-50.
shoganai
10/22/14 8:33am
agreed. its performance. i don't care how many firesides he holds. and even
johnnycarson
10/22/14 8:32am
RE: 1. Rose is more personally like-able than Bronco.
Twin Roots
10/22/14 8:17am
Wait, you mean missing personnel matters?
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:21am
RE: Wait, you mean missing personnel matters?
Twin Roots
10/22/14 8:31am
(rose won 2 tourney games without davies and was a hair from the final 4)
johnnycarson
10/22/14 8:34am
BYU football isn't about the coaches and players, it's about the fans
OpusX
10/22/14 8:17am
I agree that I wish he was better about this, but do we want a coach or a PR guy
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:21am
Football>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Bas ketball
byutx
10/22/14 8:19am
If you were at Duke, you wouldn't think that. Neither would I.
OpusX
10/22/14 8:21am
Look at the numbers, Duke Football still makes more than double what Duke
TheDeek
10/22/14 8:21am
Duke fans don't care more about Duke football. The money comes from P5
BlueK
10/22/14 8:27am
and yet, in the last few years, they've learned how to play the foosball
TheDeek
10/22/14 8:28am
And The Lego Movie made a bunch more money than 12 Years a Slave
OpusX
10/22/14 8:29am
I'd rather watch The Lego Movie than Duke Basketball... talk about a snooze fest
TheDeek
10/22/14 8:34am
Why do you think you get to decide how other people esteem various sports?
byutx
10/22/14 8:29am
This... when Basketball stinks, BYU loses maybe $1MM.... When Football stinks
TheDeek
10/22/14 8:21am
so it's just about money? In that case, let's let Holmoe decide if Bronco is ok
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:22am
It's always about Money... P5 vs G5 is all about money
TheDeek
10/22/14 8:22am
In that case, in looking for a new coach, let's make marketability the
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:29am
holy cow, seriously... re-read what you just posted. Edit it before I respond...
TheDeek
10/22/14 8:36am
There is not really much that separates Rose and Bronco at this point
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:21am
Every Rose has its thorn
braddahmike
10/22/14 8:27am
Because he had cancer.
John Doe
10/22/14 8:28am
there's something to be said for this. Rose won the media overcoming that
runnincoug
10/22/14 8:30am
But he's also the best basketball coach we've ever had
BlueK
10/22/14 8:38am
Dave Rose's coaching tree at least has a head coach in it.
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:34am
<< Deleted >>
roseyscenario
10/22/14 8:44am
Rose and Bronco are both fine coaches and both deserve more support
Coogar2
10/22/14 8:47am
He only has to be one of the 64 teams selected
BYU4eVeR
10/22/14 8:48am
64/340 = top 18% in D1. I guarantee Bronco would be very well liked if his teams
BlueK
10/22/14 8:50am
3 years since his last conference championship and he is actually really
concolor couguar
10/22/14 8:53am
Has Dave Rose ever lost 8 straight games? That right there is the equivalent to
sandtrapcougar
10/22/14 8:55am
Rose more effective for the greater mission?
roseyscenario
10/22/14 8:57am
Very different sports. Should be winning much more given the talent in
Jam Master J
10/22/14 8:59am
Fans can make lame excuses about PR skills and so forth
Indy Coug
10/22/14 9:00am
I would be thrilled with a top 25 finish. That is my measure for Bronco and it
concolor couguar
10/22/14 9:02am
Yes, exactly.
runnincoug
10/22/14 9:58am
Great write up. I'm 100% on board with your thoughts
nslscougar
10/22/14 9:20am
I like the way Rose substitutes for the most part. I hate the way bronco deals
budYu
10/22/14 9:31am
Yes, let's just criticize anyone and everyone whenever they lose...
cougarnerd
10/22/14 9:47am
It's fair. They are professionals, we can criticize them because we pay $$ to
thebruce
10/22/14 9:50am
On the player development issue it is much easier to make the NFL than NBA
Blue Cougar
10/22/14 10:55am
Still, Bronco has had stars in the NFL, legitimate stars. And yet we say he
runnincoug
10/22/14 11:24am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
