Do you know at what point Bronco came up with the 1 year probationary thing for Manti? Was it before or after he refused to fess up to drinking? I'd be surprised if it were before...because what you're saying surely has a point. The problem is, you're only comparing the crimes of the two recruits in question. And as I keep saying, there were many other things involved unique to each case.
I'm certainly not a fan of many of the things Bronco did while recruiting, but I also witnessed time & again over the years that those who accused Bronco of arrogance were often pretty arrogant themselves. And that's the general impression I got with the interaction between he & the Teo family.
I certainly don't mind an LDS kid choosing a place like ND over BYU, but at least be respectful when BYU flies you in to roll out the red carpet for you.
mutu.