My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Mar 23, 2017
12:56
:32
pm
IndependentGeorge
All-American
Not sure what your point is. My understanding is that in the polls asking
us the rating of a classic band, it is implied that we are rating their quality effective as of being in their prime.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
IndependentGeorge
Previous username
Y-er
New username
BeefNoodleCoug
Bio page
IndependentGeorge
Joined
Dec 3, 2011
Last login
Aug 28, 2017
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
FYI: Every band that is 30 years past their prime is properly rated.
Sea Chicken
3/23/17 12:45pm
RE: FYI: Every band that is 30 years past their prime is properly rated.
LaVellIfIKnow
3/23/17 12:49pm
You think the Rolling Stones are overrated?
reagan21
3/23/17 12:50pm
Depends. How much do you like them?
LaVellIfIKnow
3/23/17 12:51pm
I don't like them, but I recognize what they did for Rock n Roll.
reagan21
3/23/17 12:53pm
Tattoo You was pretty good
Sea Chicken
3/23/17 12:55pm
Besides "Start Me Up" what does it have...and I think Start Me Up sucks
reagan21
3/23/17 12:58pm
Hang Fire and Waiting on a Friend both got a lot of radio play
Sea Chicken
3/23/17 1:00pm
Radio play is mostly politics. It could have been a great album but radio play
reagan21
3/23/17 1:04pm
Yes
Frank Castiglione
3/23/17 1:06pm
Conversely, the Who is probably under rated when compared to them.
Belboz
3/23/17 1:04pm
Yes to this as well
Frank Castiglione
3/23/17 1:07pm
And that rating is "Stadium of Fire headliner (when there's no country act available)"
foofcoug
3/23/17 12:49pm
If someone is in the Rock of Roll Hall of Fame there is no way they can be underrated
Indy Coug
3/23/17 12:53pm
Madonna. Donna Summer. ABBA.
foofcoug
3/23/17 1:00pm
You can be overrated, just not underrated
Indy Coug
3/23/17 1:02pm
Oh, they're all underrated.
foofcoug
3/23/17 1:03pm
ABBA is underrated?
reagan21
3/23/17 1:07pm
RE: ABBA is underrated?
foofcoug
3/23/17 1:09pm
The meme says yes, so I guess they are
reagan21
3/23/17 1:10pm
ABBA was certainly not underpopular, but the critics could not look past their
spoxjox
3/23/17 1:34pm
I don't agree with that at all. Someone can be in the HOF and not thought of as
reagan21
3/23/17 1:03pm
Not sure what your point is. My understanding is that in the polls asking
IndependentGeorge
3/23/17 12:56pm
Generally the only test to prove whether something is
Sea Chicken
3/23/17 12:59pm
If you're still wondering how a band is rated 30 years later, they did something right to still be relevant.
SpiffCoug
3/23/17 2:30pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad