BYU won the whole thing in my lifetime. Now they're almost second class

Report problem with this ad

Jul 13, 2017
12:30:31pm

fbguru All-American

citizens. I'd go with B12. Especially since I also like non-football sports.

Report problem with this ad

fbguru

Bio page: fbguru
Joined: Jul 12, 2008
Last login: May 18, 2024
Total posts: 15,343 (78 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: If you could only have one, which would it be?

frontrowcougar

7/13/17 12:17pm

I think you have to go recruiting class.

byupacker

7/13/17 12:18pm

But the end goal is CFP. #1 recruiting class doesn't always mean CFP

DanSmith

7/13/17 12:22pm

Right, but one CFP playoff appearance

byupacker

7/13/17 12:25pm

You have a lot of faith in what a flash in the pan recruiting class would

frontrowcougar

7/13/17 12:27pm

Why choose "possibly a CFB appearance" when another option guarantees an

frontrowcougar

7/13/17 12:23pm

Texas did that as recently as 2012

BrutustheBrash

7/13/17 12:23pm

I can't imagine choosing anything besides CFP...

DanSmith

7/13/17 12:19pm

Big12 membership would be better long term than one playoff appearance

Backcountry

7/13/17 12:27pm

A CFP would kinda mean B12 membership isn't a necessity

DanSmith

7/13/17 12:28pm

Wrong.

SandYFan

7/13/17 1:17pm

BYU won the whole thing in my lifetime. Now they're almost second class

fbguru

7/13/17 12:30pm

I agree to an extent, but the Big 12 is kind of a second-class P5 conference

ByuMba90

7/13/17 12:41pm

Better to be in P5 than out.

SandYFan

7/13/17 1:17pm

Does one exclude the other? Big12 means reaching college playoffs never happens?

Preppy

7/13/17 12:49pm

Not getting into a P5 conference means BYU football dies. It's the only choice.

SandYFan

7/13/17 1:17pm

Recruiting can be overrated at times

joFan

7/13/17 1:22pm

I have a tough time with this poll because of the correlation between options

MAcc15Coug

7/13/17 1:39pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad