I watch parts of several games every weekend. Switching from BYU to any other game and the difference in play-makers seems so noticeable, to me.
I can turn on about any game and seem players doing things, consistently, that I would consider OUTSTANDING if I saw a BYU player do. Simple things - a good cut, a running decision that gains extra yards, a difficult catch, etc.
BYU's players get exactly what the defense allows, but hardly anything more, ever.