My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 22, 2017
11:05
:34
pm
RalphWiggam
All-American
See above post. Why don’t we have good QB play? How did tanner regress so much
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
RalphWiggam
Bio page
RalphWiggam
Joined
Feb 3, 2005
Last login
Jun 20, 2024
Total posts
33,449 (2,185 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
BYU and the Green Bay Packers...two cautionary tales
holyyewtbatman
11/22/17 9:37pm
holy newt batman. nice post.
Cougarclaw
11/22/17 9:41pm
Couple problems with your example. First, BYU was healthy vs Portland, LSU, and
Blueto
11/22/17 9:44pm
RE: Couple problems with your example. First, BYU was healthy vs Portland, LSU,
holyyewtbatman
11/22/17 9:46pm
Your entire post is pride. Drop the pride and realize that we don't have a qb or
Phcole
11/22/17 9:47pm
RE: Your entire post is pride. Drop the pride and realize that we don't have a
holyyewtbatman
11/22/17 9:53pm
We have bad players at many more positions than two
ColumbusCoug
11/22/17 9:54pm
Tanner Mangum is a Elite 11 MVP who threw for 3500 yrs as freshman. Squally
Blueto
11/22/17 9:54pm
Squally transferee because he wasn’t going to see time at WSU...Tanner was given
ColumbusCoug
11/22/17 9:55pm
Our current players are not much worse than what BYU typically has. Sorry.
Blueto
11/22/17 9:58pm
Dude, in 2015 Algae Brown and "just not good" Mangum were our starting QB and RB
WSUV
11/23/17 12:09am
He threw those yards to one of our best receiving corps in the 21st century.
Phcole
11/22/17 10:05pm
Agreed, our talent is on par with where it was with Bronco.
Dynasty1
11/22/17 10:13pm
No its not. Who makes the NFL from this team? Though he didn't bring in a ton,
IronPotato
11/22/17 10:20pm
Mangum, Koroma, Kanuch, Linehan, Kaufusi, Taki Taki, Pauu, Warner, Hadley,
Dynasty1
11/22/17 10:25pm
We should beat those teams. Yes. NFL talent? No.
IronPotato
11/22/17 10:27pm
We didn't have a bunch of NFL talent a few years ago but yet could compete
Dynasty1
11/22/17 10:32pm
We did compete with lower P5 teams and G5. I thin Kalani carries a big part
IronPotato
11/22/17 10:35pm
Um...Bronco was notorious for having little to no NFL talent. In fact it's one
Blueto
11/22/17 10:30pm
Hill and Mangum looked NFL caliber under Bronco. No qb will ever look NFL caliber under Sitake.
Brisco
11/22/17 11:35pm
That Tanner Mangum doesn't exist anymore. No one cares about Elite 11 6 years
IronPotato
11/22/17 10:17pm
He was a freshman all American 2 years ago
Dynasty1
11/22/17 10:20pm
Actually taysom looked good last year, we just had no receivers.
Phcole
11/22/17 10:25pm
Statistically it was by far the worst year of his career
Dynasty1
11/22/17 10:30pm
He certainly wasn't as explosive last year, I was just talking about passing
Phcole
11/22/17 10:33pm
90% is pretty high. There were drops, but he couldn't throw last year either.
IronPotato
11/22/17 10:30pm
He also mssed 3 springs in a row.
BYURider
11/22/17 11:47pm
Tanner won't be in the NFL. He's digressed substantially. All the announcers
IronPotato
11/22/17 10:29pm
All in his own. It's so weird. Why did he choose to digress?
Blueto
11/22/17 10:32pm
Mental. Bad technique. Stares down WR. Inferior WRs.
CougarThug
11/22/17 11:59pm
Lol, that's a dumb question. Coaching is part of it. He can't run Detmers
IronPotato
11/23/17 7:51am
???
ColonelMustard
11/23/17 4:48pm
I'm guessing GB would beat Cleveland with their backup QB and RB.
mudpupper
11/22/17 9:56pm
Was going to post the same thing but figured someone else already had
ColonelMustard
11/23/17 8:55am
Agreed. Injuries have certainly taken a toll on the team. I still can't figure
CT98
11/22/17 9:47pm
The difference is that none of our QBs or RBs are any good. Rogers is a HOF.
IronPotato
11/22/17 10:09pm
So with Tanner we went 2-5... without... 1-3... about to be 1-4...
Coug
11/22/17 10:22pm
I have been saying this, my thoughts exactly
Y'sWoody
11/22/17 10:26pm
Um...those two situations aren’t remotely comparable.
RalphWiggam
11/22/17 10:39pm
RE: Um...those two situations aren’t remotely comparable.
holyyewtbatman
11/22/17 10:51pm
But the bigger point is this...why don’t we have solid QB okay?
RalphWiggam
11/22/17 11:03pm
I get your point 100%! And i dont get how others don't
BYURider
11/22/17 11:52pm
They are comparable as he said in follow up
SpudCoug
11/22/17 11:00pm
See above post. Why don’t we have good QB play? How did tanner regress so much
RalphWiggam
11/22/17 11:05pm
RE: See above post. Why don’t we have good QB play? How did tanner
holyyewtbatman
11/22/17 11:19pm
The offense has improved this year despite all the injuries and QB shuffle. But
BYURider
11/22/17 11:56pm
For the 100th time. This team might’ve looked the most unprepared,
Gerald-DeGroot
11/23/17 2:18am
Must. Resist. Agreeing. With. You...
gmoney7
11/23/17 8:35am
Apples and oranges.
BYUlv
11/23/17 11:44am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
