4 of the 5 most successful OCs in BYU history were “inexperienced”

Report problem with this ad

Dec 12, 2017
8:51:00pm

CaliWG All-American

Only Scovil was a coordinator before coming to BYU.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 12, 2017 at 8:51:00pm

Message modified by CaliWG on Dec 12, 2017 at 9:10:55pm

Report problem with this ad

CaliWG

Bio page: CaliWG
Joined: Feb 8, 2005
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 24,194 (1,553 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If Kalani actually hires Beck he is making the right choice

CaliWG

12/12/17 4:02pm

Care to give a reason why such a young, inexperienced lad

Plato

12/12/17 4:07pm

He has been part of 3 different successful offensive installs under Anae

CaliWG

12/12/17 4:13pm

I don't know how you know that he "understands" those things, but OK.

Plato

12/12/17 5:18pm

Beck has worked 8 yrs with one of the most rigid, execution-based coaches in CFB

CaliWG

12/12/17 5:26pm

I would rather have somebody who has limtied experience and is hungry than

molodyets

12/12/17 4:14pm

Yes. Hunger as a primary qualification. Great hiring strategy.

Plato

12/12/17 5:11pm

Care to give your great list of reasons why it's so bad?

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 5:13pm

Sure, why would anyone want an up-and-coming guy with 6 years

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 4:18pm

If he's successful as an OC at BYU he could be HC at BYU sooner than you think.

Windward_Coug

12/12/17 4:22pm

He could be a solid candidate in the future. I'd love to see him even

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 4:25pm

He'd have to take a paycut to go fcs HC. He's making 300k at uva

thebruce

12/12/17 5:15pm

Not everyone makes money moves. They can make status moves.

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 5:21pm

I don't think going fcs is a step forward. Going for a fbs OC job

thebruce

12/12/17 5:24pm

Yes, I listed that. And if you can go from middle or low FBS OC to P5 OC,

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 5:32pm

He has previous OC experience. Turned an NCAA D2 team's offense from worst in

JamesWestfall

12/12/17 5:54pm

I want someone that's actually called plays before.

Windward_Coug

12/12/17 4:08pm

Then do your research on Beck and get back to us.

Coug

12/12/17 4:09pm

This is one of the most overrated things on CB.

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 4:10pm

Seriously it's amazing.

Coug

12/12/17 4:12pm

Agreed. Actually calling of plays is the least critical part of the OC's job imo

fulano

12/12/17 4:30pm

RE: I want someone that's actually called plays before.

CrashMcLarson

12/12/17 4:10pm

Interesting. Never knew there was an NCAA team in Canada. Never knew he

Windward_Coug

12/12/17 4:12pm

There is but they're garbage

Cashmeousside

12/12/17 4:39pm

Wow their current HC is 0-29. I thought we had problems

Windward_Coug

12/12/17 4:50pm

<< Deleted >>

Deleted

12/12/17 4:15pm

Sounds like you endorse Jason Beck for OC

Jericho

12/12/17 5:09pm

So more on-the-job training...

CougarCanuck76

12/12/17 4:41pm

If this were true, there would be no OC's, no HC's...

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 4:50pm

This shouldn't be that way at BYU

CougarCanuck76

12/12/17 5:51pm

Why? That's crazy. It's not necessary.

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 5:56pm

Experience isn't necessary?

CougarCanuck76

12/12/17 6:28pm

It's not necessary for BYU to 100% of the time, hire

Lip Gallagher

12/12/17 6:54pm

How about once in a while?

CougarCanuck76

12/13/17 7:39am

Sure. Weigh everything and decide what comes out on top in terms of

Lip Gallagher

12/13/17 12:46pm

BYU has some inherent disadvantages for this sort of thing

Jericho

12/12/17 6:01pm

In a word, nope.

bbqelitist

12/12/17 7:25pm

No he’s not. We need someone with experience and proven.

Gerald-DeGroot

12/12/17 7:30pm

4 of the 5 most successful OCs in BYU history were “inexperienced”

CaliWG

12/12/17 8:51pm

Yeah I don’t care. Right now we need an experienced and proven OC

Gerald-DeGroot

12/12/17 10:01pm

Because non-washed up proven D1 OCs are lining up at BYU’s front door, right?

CaliWG

12/12/17 10:17pm

I’m just saying that’s what we need.

Posting on CougarBoard