Yeah. I understood you saying you pull two out and then look and see one is

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Feb 21, 2018
2:29:13pm

jcase16byu Starter

Yeah. I understood you saying you pull two out and then look and see one is

red. What's the probability of the second being blue? That would be 50%. Timing changes this.

Report problem with this ad

jcase16byu

Bio page: jcase16byu
Joined: Jul 9, 2013
Last login: Apr 26, 2024
Total posts: 2,389 (71 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Basic probability question for you

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 12:45pm

66%?

JuicyJam

2/21/18 12:46pm

Yes

Great38

2/21/18 12:50pm

50/50--it either is or it isn't.

Carnac

2/21/18 12:47pm

Here’s why I ask

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 12:50pm

Are you a student at BYU or Utah?

Carnac

2/21/18 12:52pm

She is solving the probability that the first is red AND the second is blue

Great38

2/21/18 12:55pm

The whole class was asking why it shouldn’t be 2/3

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 12:58pm

if the question you posted is verbatim from your notes

The Shazad

2/21/18 12:59pm

In that case, 2/3. It's a conditional probability question.

Great38

2/21/18 1:02pm

That is a different question

FiveTen-BuckEighty

2/21/18 12:55pm

Doesn't sound like you are answering the same question to me.

JuicyJam

2/21/18 12:56pm

Right. She answered a different question than what was on the notes

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 1:00pm

So you select the two balls at the same time or one at a time?

Big Wally D

2/21/18 12:52pm

One at a time

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 12:52pm

I agree with Juicy and their question is worded wrong if the professor

Big Wally D

2/21/18 12:57pm

^^THIS^^ The key to this problem is WHEN...

jomo

2/21/18 12:58pm

Yeah. I understood you saying you pull two out and then look and see one is

jcase16byu

2/21/18 2:29pm

is this like Let's Make a Deal where the % changes based on info from 1st choice

byujag

2/21/18 12:55pm

Not really, that would require that they pull a ball out of the bag and show

Skeptical Optimist

2/21/18 1:00pm

<< Deleted >>

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 1:05pm

She's wrong. Blow her mind with the let's make a deal probability question.

cougar1961

2/21/18 1:11pm

wow

The Shazad

2/21/18 1:14pm

TNT has but one question.

JuicyJam

2/21/18 1:36pm

Somebody email her the link to this thread on CB (email at top left of image)

FiveTen-BuckEighty

2/21/18 3:18pm

Maybe this kid was right after all...

Great38

2/21/18 1:08pm

Same professor here too

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 1:09pm

What class is this?

JuicyJam

2/21/18 1:42pm

Stats 1040

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 1:55pm

I work with a few statisticians from USU, maybe I should give them a hard time.

Great38

2/21/18 2:01pm

Go for it. She’s a grad student too

Alpi Gusto

2/21/18 2:08pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad