His averages through two seasons compared to Jimmer:

Points per game: 14.7 vs 11.5

3pt Percentage: 37.8%(455 attempts) vs 35.9% (264 attempts)

Free Throw %: 84.3% (178 attempts) vs 84.8% (178 attempts)

Rebounds per game: 3.3 vs 1.8

Assists per game: 2.5 vs 2.9

Steals per game: 1.5 vs 1.1

Turnovers per game: 1.7 vs 1.9

AND most importantly, he took a swing at Brandon Taylor. 

Don't cherry pick a few of his bad games. If you want to do that, point out the following games for Elijah Bryant:

#25 Alabama 5pts 2-12

#14 Gonzaga 4pts 1-11

9pts, 3-23 shooting

Here are some other stats from the games you mentioned

VS SMC
WCC Tourney 0-7 0 points 25 minutes - led the team in assists (2) and blocks (1), had 3 rebounds
at Moraga 3/8 9 points 32 minutes - 5 steals, 2 rebounds, 2 assists
at BYU 2/10 4 points 31 minutes - led the team in assists with 5, and had 6 rebounds (more than Mika)

VS GU
at BYU 1/6 2 points 20 minutes - 2 rebs, 1 assist, 1 steal, 1 block 
at GU 2/11 9 points in 34 minutes - 4 rebs, 3 steals, 2 assists

Yeah, he had bad scoring games, so does everyone. But you're blind if you don't think he is a special player for BYU.