High school stars irrelevant?

Report problem with this ad

May 17, 2018
10:23:36pm

BYURider Walk-on

Based on what we've seen since they have played in college, I'd give Childs a
3-star, and everyone else a 2-star.

Report problem with this ad

BYURider

Bio page: BYURider
Joined: Feb 9, 2009
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 5,412 (9 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Your 2018-19 BYU basketball team

bcriddle Walk On of The Year 2006

5/17/18 10:09pm

That’s a solid lineup

billyrust

5/17/18 10:11pm

In high school.

Ocho Cuatro

5/17/18 11:27pm

Need someone to develop into lights out 3 pt shooter

Run-DMT

5/17/18 10:13pm

Worthington.

Gerald-DeGroot

5/18/18 1:27am

That's impressive, but something inside of me refuses to get excited

HighHorse

5/17/18 10:19pm

You could go cheer for the Utes. Maybe that would excite you.

rockyrd

5/17/18 10:26pm

Don't be ridiculous

HighHorse

5/17/18 10:32pm

RE: You could go cheer for the Utes. Maybe that would excite you.

Gerald-DeGroot

5/18/18 1:32am

RE: That's impressive, but something inside of me refuses to get excited

Roko's Basilisk

5/18/18 10:29am

High school stars irrelevant?

BYURider

5/17/18 10:23pm

WPOTD

Indy Coug

5/17/18 10:25pm

Childs has been very effective and clearly deserving of his 4 stars

PHXSUNS31

5/17/18 10:58pm

Get him Criddle!

Superman21

5/17/18 11:07pm

Someone bm this to Criddle, stat!

UberDeek

5/17/18 11:09pm

Sad because they should actually be good

Dillinger

5/17/18 10:27pm

has the potential to be the most underperforming team in history

BlueFrog

5/17/18 10:32pm

Was Worthington really a 3 star?

johnnybyu

5/17/18 10:36pm

Yeah, offers from BYU, Princeton, Penn and others

bcriddle

5/17/18 10:44pm

In football? Recruited by Wisconsin, BYU, Stanford....

AF Cougar

5/17/18 10:49pm

What was his rating as a FB player? If you know.

soupie

5/17/18 11:57pm

90% of that will end up being the 2019-2020 team as well.

d-coug

5/17/18 10:39pm

Yep, because when we think of BYU basketball recently, we think roster stability

billyrust

5/17/18 10:42pm

Point taken, but only Shaw, Cannon and Worthington are SRs.

d-coug

5/17/18 10:52pm

Next year baby!

Gerald-DeGroot

5/18/18 1:26am

Not for sure roster. But all who played double digit minutes are back.

roseyscenario

5/17/18 10:49pm

Hmmm... that leaves Dastrup (7.9 min), Bergerson (3.7), Troy (1.5) and Shaw (1.0)

ColoSpgs

5/18/18 8:20am

That's going to set up for some awesome

LaVellIfIKnow

5/17/18 10:53pm

Can you imagine if this team had Mika and Bryant

Tuskaloosa Cougar

5/17/18 11:01pm

They would still underperform

thebruce

5/17/18 11:07pm

Why?

basman

5/18/18 6:54am

Because relative to talent we have underperformed the last few years

thebruce

5/18/18 7:17am

And no offense to Eli and Mika

thebruce

5/18/18 7:19am

Every team in the country goes through this BYU does not

dodgersjazzcougs

5/18/18 9:02am

No excuse for sucking.

Countcougula

5/17/18 11:42pm

Love me some Criddle but this is incredible deceiving

ColumbusCoug

5/17/18 11:54pm

Childs has lived up to his 4-star billing. Haws and Emery have both shown

jreid191

5/18/18 12:09am

Hey! Shhhhhhhhh! Okay Mr. Negative.

Gerald-DeGroot

5/18/18 1:34am

He’s simply showing their ranking. Not the results.

SouthernBlueBlood

5/18/18 4:42am

Hence the value (or not) of recruiting rankings.

basman

5/18/18 6:55am

Year before last they started 5 four stars and had another off the bench and

JamesWestfall

5/18/18 9:17am

Too bad Seljaas couldn’t hit the broad side of a barn this year

Heath Squashwell

5/18/18 9:51am

Strange because he could hit the side of the backboard.

JuicyJam

5/18/18 9:53am

If your best player stays an extra year, it really makes a difference.

Coogar2

5/18/18 12:23pm

Is Kolby Lee really a 4 star?

robin

5/18/18 1:51pm

He is on ESPN recruiting site.

Benfica1

5/18/18 1:53pm

ESPN loves BYU

Indy Coug

5/18/18 1:57pm

Have we ever had a 5* player? if so, who?

Hill4Heisman

5/18/18 2:01pm

Bradley probably qualifies, but recruiting ratings didn't exist as such back then

Indy Coug

5/18/18 2:32pm

Danny Ainge is only 3 sport 1st Team Parade All-American ever! Does he Count?

roseyscenario

5/18/18 7:50pm

Garner Meads and Justin Wiedauer were McDonalds AA. Not sure of stars though.

wok your dog

5/18/18 10:20pm

How many stars was Jimmer?

Croweater

5/18/18 7:13pm

soupie

5/18/18 7:32pm

And yet the better of them all

Heinz57

5/19/18 11:55am

It's all such a guessing game. Sure it's a good recognition for past

soupie

5/19/18 12:30pm

It is a pattern for what those tendencies are, good or bad

Posting on CougarBoard