Yeah, that season could have been so much different if Reed hadn't gotten

Jul 19, 2018
3:22:37pm

BYUFootballisBack Starter

injured. When he came back he wasn't the same. But we literally had nobody to fill his spot, and that made it easier for TCU to stop us

Report problem with this ad

BYUFootballisBack

Previous username: oddsewer
Bio page: BYUFootballisBack
Joined: Apr 29, 2007
Last login: May 1, 2024
Total posts: 14,008 (722 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What is the best WR trio in BYU history?

Ham

7/19/18 1:53pm

I think you're forcing the "trio" thing. 2008 was awesome, but Reed White really had nothing to do with that.

jdub

7/19/18 1:57pm

Just trying to take a deeper look at the position group as a whole.

Ham

7/19/18 1:59pm

<< Deleted >>

Cougazul

7/19/18 2:25pm

And who are the oppnonents, etc.

Ham

7/19/18 2:33pm

That’s the idea. He’s looking at best overall group of 3. So if the top 2 are

RdF3

7/19/18 1:59pm

Except, in this case, the top 2 are better than any other trio he mentioned. In fact, mainly, the top 1.

jdub

7/19/18 2:16pm

I doubt anyone argues that Collie doesn't have the single greatest season of any

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 2:21pm

2006 is a great example of this John Beck was slinging the ball to everyone

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 3:30pm

Man I miss those days, BYU was rolling its too bad we lost those nailbiters to

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 4:28pm

I like to pretend I remember every player at BYU.....no idea who Reed White is.

mokelembembe

7/19/18 3:05pm

Yeah, that season could have been so much different if Reed hadn't gotten

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 3:22pm

you have to go Boyce, Nyberg and MM. though they did have the GOAT

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 1:58pm

trom2foot3

7/19/18 2:02pm

I think you've got to include TEs in the conversation

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 2:03pm

you include TE's, the 1990 group still kills - you add 1st team AA, Chris Smith.

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:05pm

Actually pretty close, 1990 - 3213 total, 2008 - 3165, TDs 1990 loses 4 because

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 2:08pm

1996 you add Chad Lewis and Itula Mili. In 2006 you add Johnny Harline

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 2:10pm

Dustin Johnson also in 1996. Three excellent TEs that year!

Ham

7/19/18 2:12pm

dustin johnson was a FB

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:24pm

Hm. Not according to cougarstats.

Ham

7/19/18 2:33pm

yeah, that's wrong. if you remember watching those teams, you know he

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:37pm

give me smith over any of those guys.

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:25pm

Not competing, just listing great TEs. There's a lot of 'em!

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 3:24pm

Yeah... it was hard not including Harline and Pitta.

Ham

7/19/18 2:11pm

Koz, Bellini, Haysbert >>>>> the rest on that list

fulano

7/19/18 2:04pm

Going solely off yardage is difficult as well because you gotta control for QB

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 2:11pm

Would have loved to see Hoffman and Apo with Beck or Hall.

Lip Gallagher

7/19/18 3:03pm

Plater, Kozlowski and Balholm and Hudson at TE

RC Vikings

7/19/18 2:28pm

any trio with Collie

BYURider

7/19/18 2:41pm

Watkins, Collie, and whoever in 2004.

HBCoug

7/19/18 2:48pm

this is the correct answer

Mayor of Cougartown

7/19/18 3:23pm

4.3 speed and route running ability that could make DB's cry. best pair ever...

icecougar

7/19/18 3:28pm

Collie got open against anyone in college, AND, anyone in the NFL

BYURider

7/19/18 3:57pm

This is the group that came to my mind as well. (Stats)

cucciolo25

7/19/18 4:24pm

Somewhere, Reed White is smiling.

cougarnw

7/19/18 4:03pm

I'd like to see attempts listed. Might give a better idea of who went after the

cdr88

7/19/18 6:07pm

In bizarro BYU history Collie stays in ‘09

ProvoSpain

7/19/18 6:13pm

Add tight ends and this would be a better discussion

D.T. Survivor

7/19/18 6:16pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad