In bizarro BYU history Collie stays in ‘09

Report problem with this ad

Jul 19, 2018
6:13:40pm

ProvoSpain Redshirt Freshman

Hoffman doesn’t redshirt, and together with Pitta all records are broken.

*sigh

Report problem with this ad

ProvoSpain

Bio page: ProvoSpain
Joined: Sep 4, 2013
Last login: May 12, 2024
Total posts: 730 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What is the best WR trio in BYU history?

Ham

7/19/18 1:53pm

I think you're forcing the "trio" thing. 2008 was awesome, but Reed White really had nothing to do with that.

jdub

7/19/18 1:57pm

Just trying to take a deeper look at the position group as a whole.

Ham

7/19/18 1:59pm

<< Deleted >>

Cougazul

7/19/18 2:25pm

And who are the oppnonents, etc.

Ham

7/19/18 2:33pm

That’s the idea. He’s looking at best overall group of 3. So if the top 2 are

RdF3

7/19/18 1:59pm

Except, in this case, the top 2 are better than any other trio he mentioned. In fact, mainly, the top 1.

jdub

7/19/18 2:16pm

I doubt anyone argues that Collie doesn't have the single greatest season of any

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 2:21pm

2006 is a great example of this John Beck was slinging the ball to everyone

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 3:30pm

Man I miss those days, BYU was rolling its too bad we lost those nailbiters to

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 4:28pm

I like to pretend I remember every player at BYU.....no idea who Reed White is.

mokelembembe

7/19/18 3:05pm

Yeah, that season could have been so much different if Reed hadn't gotten

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 3:22pm

you have to go Boyce, Nyberg and MM. though they did have the GOAT

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 1:58pm

trom2foot3

7/19/18 2:02pm

I think you've got to include TEs in the conversation

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 2:03pm

you include TE's, the 1990 group still kills - you add 1st team AA, Chris Smith.

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:05pm

Actually pretty close, 1990 - 3213 total, 2008 - 3165, TDs 1990 loses 4 because

BYUFootballisBack

7/19/18 2:08pm

1996 you add Chad Lewis and Itula Mili. In 2006 you add Johnny Harline

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 2:10pm

Dustin Johnson also in 1996. Three excellent TEs that year!

Ham

7/19/18 2:12pm

dustin johnson was a FB

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:24pm

Hm. Not according to cougarstats.

Ham

7/19/18 2:33pm

yeah, that's wrong. if you remember watching those teams, you know he

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:37pm

give me smith over any of those guys.

smokymountainrain

7/19/18 2:25pm

Not competing, just listing great TEs. There's a lot of 'em!

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 3:24pm

Yeah... it was hard not including Harline and Pitta.

Ham

7/19/18 2:11pm

Koz, Bellini, Haysbert >>>>> the rest on that list

fulano

7/19/18 2:04pm

Going solely off yardage is difficult as well because you gotta control for QB

WhiteKnight

7/19/18 2:11pm

Would have loved to see Hoffman and Apo with Beck or Hall.

Lip Gallagher

7/19/18 3:03pm

Plater, Kozlowski and Balholm and Hudson at TE

RC Vikings

7/19/18 2:28pm

any trio with Collie

BYURider

7/19/18 2:41pm

Watkins, Collie, and whoever in 2004.

HBCoug

7/19/18 2:48pm

this is the correct answer

Mayor of Cougartown

7/19/18 3:23pm

4.3 speed and route running ability that could make DB's cry. best pair ever...

icecougar

7/19/18 3:28pm

Collie got open against anyone in college, AND, anyone in the NFL

BYURider

7/19/18 3:57pm

This is the group that came to my mind as well. (Stats)

cucciolo25

7/19/18 4:24pm

Somewhere, Reed White is smiling.

cougarnw

7/19/18 4:03pm

I'd like to see attempts listed. Might give a better idea of who went after the

cdr88

7/19/18 6:07pm

In bizarro BYU history Collie stays in ‘09

ProvoSpain

7/19/18 6:13pm

Add tight ends and this would be a better discussion

D.T. Survivor

7/19/18 6:16pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad