My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 15, 2018
12:55
:31
pm
Mr. Scoobs
All-American
Hoge had a better QBR but when you are comparing to the worst it don’t matter
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Mr. Scoobs
Previous username
Alm
Bio page
Mr. Scoobs
Joined
Sep 8, 2011
Last login
Jun 6, 2024
Total posts
12,057 (184 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
QB Hoge > QB Mangum. impossible to say vs Wilson.
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:14pm
Based on last year only, I agree. I don't know about now though.
Hawk Talons
8/15/18 12:16pm
Beau had worse passing stats than Mangum and Critch, so it's just not true
Jericho
8/15/18 12:17pm
I think you have to factor in both passing and running
Hawk Talons
8/15/18 12:19pm
Grimes doesn't want a run first QB. He wants a passing QB
Jericho
8/15/18 12:21pm
his stats were pretty much the same as Mangum, but the running puts him
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:20pm
No, they were worse. Running *maybe made him about even
Jericho
8/15/18 12:22pm
wrong.
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:30pm
3/10 vs Fresno State? Yeah, he's a great passer...
Jericho
8/15/18 12:32pm
mangum threw the ball 33 times for only 160 yards vs Fresno. pathetic.
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:46pm
And he still outplayed Beau... which is why Beau is QB4 at best if he were still
Jericho
8/15/18 12:50pm
one game sample. i've already provided season numbers where Hoge > Mangum
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:51pm
Yet you look at USU as a good reason for why he is so good
Jericho
8/15/18 12:54pm
Mangum went from top 30 in QBR as a freshman to #111 last year.
Mr. Scoobs
8/15/18 12:22pm
and he was still a better passer than Beau...
Jericho
8/15/18 12:23pm
Hoge had a better QBR but when you are comparing to the worst it don’t matter
Mr. Scoobs
8/15/18 12:55pm
exactly. its not as if i'm complimenting Hoge's QB ability here.
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:56pm
Well, I'm not arguing that Tanner was great last year. He sucked. All of our
Jericho
8/15/18 1:05pm
#superhottakes
cheezedawg
8/15/18 12:17pm
Hi Merrill. Good interview this morning.
Ash
8/15/18 12:24pm
what's funny, is saying that isn't really even a compliment to Hoge.
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:31pm
Beau's a playmaker (might I say "gunslinger"?), and with him the potential for
Hawk in the 303
8/15/18 12:26pm
What are you basing this on? 1/2 of the USU game?
TheLoneCougar
8/15/18 12:44pm
He had 9 passes in that game, so it's a huge sample size to draw on
Jericho
8/15/18 12:45pm
reality
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:47pm
Can we handpick Tanner's best stats against his worst competition and then call
BYUFootballisBack
8/15/18 12:53pm
what? there is nothing handpicked there -i posted season stats for both players
smokymountainrain
8/15/18 12:55pm
Yeah but the sample size is so small and against a bad team that it really
BYUFootballisBack
8/15/18 1:02pm
That is what you call reality? 19/39 for 364 yards in 3 games played...
TheLoneCougar
8/15/18 12:59pm
1/4, actually.
rggee
8/15/18 1:30pm
Nope
rggee
8/15/18 1:29pm
I think you just like to collect thumbs down sometimes.
whirl
8/15/18 1:40pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
