I think you just like to collect thumbs down sometimes.

Report problem with this ad

Aug 15, 2018
1:40:14pm

whirl All-American

I think you just like to collect thumbs down sometimes.

Report problem with this ad

whirl

Bio page: whirl
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
Last login: May 16, 2024
Total posts: 30,581 (15,084 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

QB Hoge > QB Mangum. impossible to say vs Wilson.

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:14pm

Based on last year only, I agree. I don't know about now though.

Hawk Talons

8/15/18 12:16pm

Beau had worse passing stats than Mangum and Critch, so it's just not true

Jericho

8/15/18 12:17pm

I think you have to factor in both passing and running

Hawk Talons

8/15/18 12:19pm

Grimes doesn't want a run first QB. He wants a passing QB

Jericho

8/15/18 12:21pm

his stats were pretty much the same as Mangum, but the running puts him

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:20pm

No, they were worse. Running *maybe made him about even

Jericho

8/15/18 12:22pm

wrong.

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:30pm

3/10 vs Fresno State? Yeah, he's a great passer...

Jericho

8/15/18 12:32pm

mangum threw the ball 33 times for only 160 yards vs Fresno. pathetic.

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:46pm

And he still outplayed Beau... which is why Beau is QB4 at best if he were still

Jericho

8/15/18 12:50pm

one game sample. i've already provided season numbers where Hoge > Mangum

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:51pm

Yet you look at USU as a good reason for why he is so good

Jericho

8/15/18 12:54pm

Mangum went from top 30 in QBR as a freshman to #111 last year.

Mr. Scoobs

8/15/18 12:22pm

and he was still a better passer than Beau...

Jericho

8/15/18 12:23pm

Hoge had a better QBR but when you are comparing to the worst it don’t matter

Mr. Scoobs

8/15/18 12:55pm

exactly. its not as if i'm complimenting Hoge's QB ability here.

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:56pm

Well, I'm not arguing that Tanner was great last year. He sucked. All of our

Jericho

8/15/18 1:05pm

#superhottakes

cheezedawg

8/15/18 12:17pm

Hi Merrill. Good interview this morning.

Ash

8/15/18 12:24pm

what's funny, is saying that isn't really even a compliment to Hoge.

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:31pm

Beau's a playmaker (might I say "gunslinger"?), and with him the potential for

Hawk in the 303

8/15/18 12:26pm

What are you basing this on? 1/2 of the USU game?

TheLoneCougar

8/15/18 12:44pm

He had 9 passes in that game, so it's a huge sample size to draw on

Jericho

8/15/18 12:45pm

reality

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:47pm

Can we handpick Tanner's best stats against his worst competition and then call

BYUFootballisBack

8/15/18 12:53pm

what? there is nothing handpicked there -i posted season stats for both players

smokymountainrain

8/15/18 12:55pm

Yeah but the sample size is so small and against a bad team that it really

BYUFootballisBack

8/15/18 1:02pm

That is what you call reality? 19/39 for 364 yards in 3 games played...

TheLoneCougar

8/15/18 12:59pm

1/4, actually.

rggee

8/15/18 1:30pm

Nope

rggee

8/15/18 1:29pm

I think you just like to collect thumbs down sometimes.

whirl

8/15/18 1:40pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad