would they rule a person like that out?  Not trying to compare me to current athletes but in my case, I wanted to stay close to home, didn't have any schools near me make anything more than walk on offers and I knew I prob wouldnt get immediate playing time at BYU so I chose to go the jucco route (think steven beo), saved money and lived at home. I had diff prioirites than a lot of guys but I was accepted to BYU and offered but chose a diff route. Why would that disqualify a guy from going back to BYU after he finished a 2 year? Seems fishy and not true. I won't believe that until I hear it in public...In fact I'm going to call my AD recource tomorrow and just ask intead of continuing with the rumor mill.