I love Tanner, but no way is he an NFL caliber QB. Good guy, average QB

Report problem with this ad

Oct 10, 2018
10:56:08pm

Zaphod Don’t Panic

Report problem with this ad

Zaphod

Previous username: Fetch
Bio page: Zaphod
Joined: Jul 9, 2002
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 48,448 (4,957 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If Tanner does get benched, I hope he feels the love from BYU fans.

cougarfanatic

10/10/18 10:29pm

+1 I have a hard time thinking he didn't get hosed a bit

seacougar

10/10/18 10:43pm

hosed? By any other standards, he got years more experience as a starter than he

maxpowers

10/10/18 10:52pm

I think each of those years has been in less-than-ideal circumstances.

seacougar

10/10/18 10:59pm

Welcome to life. TM has had as good a shot as most any.

YSMACK

10/10/18 11:01pm

He is just someone I would have like to have seen succeed. We'll never know, but

seacougar

10/10/18 11:11pm

All fair points.

YSMACK

10/10/18 11:24pm

Ummm...we all wanted him to succeed.....but he didnt...time to move on

WJCougar

10/10/18 11:32pm

and what will we do when RBs continue to miss blocks, fumble, and take bad lanes? What will we do when OL

ChinaFan

10/10/18 11:43pm

You think too much about silly things.

OneUpper

10/11/18 12:04am

yeah, those silly things that have been the real reason we lost, well, besides the defense that can't tackle, cover

ChinaFan

10/11/18 12:15am

He's a great guy and I hope he is wildly successful and happy in life.

Mrs Featerbottom

10/10/18 10:43pm

Seeing him on SC top 10 was a great moment to be a cougar fan.

bus driverman

10/10/18 10:47pm

I'm not sure about NFL dreams being gone. There have been some college QBs that made the NFL after less than

ChinaFan

10/10/18 10:51pm

I love Tanner, but no way is he an NFL caliber QB. Good guy, average QB

Zaphod

10/10/18 10:56pm

Zaphod, which 2016 post you want me to reference where you said the same about..

whiteninja

10/11/18 7:29am

Any is fine. Keep this one too.

Zaphod

10/11/18 3:35pm

Well, backup QB is the most popular player on the team!

rcbyufan

10/10/18 11:10pm

RE: If Tanner does get benched, I hope he feels the love from BYU fans.

Gerald-DeGroot

10/11/18 2:21am

RE: If Tanner does get benched, I hope he feels the love from BYU fans.

TAMUCoug

10/11/18 5:45am

He will always be remembered fondly for his first two games

Colorado

10/11/18 7:42am

RE: If Tanner does get benched, I hope he feels the love from BYU fans.

eysikal

10/11/18 7:26am

People said the same about Taysom, and now he's in the NFL.

CharlottesvilleCoug

10/11/18 7:35am

Not exactly the same thing. He's in the NFL because he is a freak athlete

Colorado

10/11/18 7:37am

Taysom single handedly dominated multiple games.

Machiavelli

10/11/18 7:58am

Tanner will be remembered for two plays:

beantownblue

10/11/18 8:21am

Uhh what? How is it overthrown if he put it in a place only his receiver

Machiavelli

10/11/18 8:26am

This post does not incorporate any football IQ

Y05

10/11/18 8:42am

Care to add any analysis about John Beck underthrowing Jonny Harline

Y05

10/11/18 8:44am

or Hall massively underthrowing Collie on 4th and 18?

Dissenter

10/12/18 8:11am

He will be remembered for QB'ing two of the biggest upsets in recent BYU history. He'll always have Lincoln and Madison

byujag

10/11/18 8:51am

He will statistically be remembered as the worst BYU QB in history to start 30

Gerald-DeGroot

10/11/18 9:36am

Why bring it up?

Machiavelli

10/11/18 11:09am

This is a BYU sports message board? It’s a statistical truth? He’s been the

Gerald-DeGroot

10/11/18 7:31pm

If a guy is done at BYU, no need to highlight his negatives.

Machiavelli

10/11/18 9:12pm

Because, sadly, that's what our pessimistic culture causes us to do

Y05

10/11/18 7:57pm

Dang... that makes me feel like a jerk.

Gerald-DeGroot

10/11/18 8:00pm

Tanner had 3 different OC in the 4 years he was on the team, I believe he had a

Posting on CougarBoard