I don't understand this one. Edgar was a great player, but I don't see why

Report problem with this ad

Jan 22, 2019
4:25:18pm

Memmo All-American

he's a Hall of Famer and avoids the steroid era stigma.

Report problem with this ad

Memmo

Previous username: (Private)
Bio page: Memmo
Joined: Feb 8, 2011
Last login: May 6, 2024
Total posts: 12,671 (746 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Welcome to the HOF, Edgar.

Vincent's Picks

1/22/19 4:20pm

I don't understand this one. Edgar was a great player, but I don't see why

Memmo

1/22/19 4:25pm

Have you seen his stats?

Vincent's Picks

1/22/19 4:26pm

Yes. Good, not great. His counting numbers are a bit low for Hall of Fame.

Memmo

1/22/19 4:32pm

He played 3rd base until he was 32. Hamstring injury took him off the field and

Vincent's Picks

1/22/19 4:34pm

He only played in the field for about 500 out of

Jdoc

1/22/19 5:07pm

The dude has an award named after him, the DH is a legit position in baseball.

FinanceCoug

1/22/19 4:38pm

Half of baseball

Stocktonblues

1/22/19 4:42pm

DH is just a hitter who rests half the time. Rivera is an interesting case.

Memmo

1/22/19 4:49pm

Do a little bit of research before posting this stuff...

TheKing

1/22/19 5:04pm

I did. His WAR ranks 115th all time. Definitely in the range, but not a

Memmo

1/22/19 5:25pm

115 out of 230ish

TheKing

1/22/19 5:29pm

I'm all for Edgar being in the HOF. But how does he get a pass on steroids?

Blue Cat

1/22/19 6:09pm

Those are fair points of question

TheKing

1/22/19 6:19pm

Joyner used steroids? Link?

Sandy Lyle

1/22/19 7:39pm

RE: Joyner used steroids? Link?

Blue Cat

1/22/19 7:48pm

Wow. Thanks

Sandy Lyle

1/22/19 7:55pm

Good days for Mariners fans are few and far between. Edgar's tweet:

Posting on CougarBoard