Evidenced by my sig fluff, I'm a big Punisher fan. I'm having a discussion with a guy at work who is also big into comic books. We're discussing screen adaptations of The Punisher. The question is, who was a better Frank Castle, Thomas Jane or Jon Bernthal? My personal opinion is that, despite the deviation from canon in the movie, I thought Thomas Jane was the better Frank. That's not to say Bernthal wasn't great. I just think Jane did a better job.

So, what say you. Who do you think was better?